@Background Pony #8665  
A continuation….
 
When Fluttershy finally pays a visit to your home, you set your dastardly plan into motion… calling your blindfolded dogs to attack. Little do you realize Fluttershy is even better with dogs than you! When the dogs start attacking, Fluttershy uses her special stare and makes the dogs stop attacking. She gives them belly rubs and makes them docile as heck! She asks you why they had blindfolds on and you reply, with your signature evil grin “You’re tougher than you look, my love… but your flesh is weak and my special tools are stronger”
 
Fluttershy starts to panic as she reaches under her dress and pulls out a glock she had in a secret holster on her thigh “ss…stand back! You…. you monster!” she stammers has she slowly steps back as he gets closer… “Please…. stop… I don’t want to have to use this…. but.. butt” has you come closer, she can feel your rancid breath “BAM” Fluttershy pulled the trigger in a state of panic, sending a bullet straight through your heart. As you lay bleeding, dead with a silver bullet logged in your heart. Fluttershy pulls out stops the tape recorder she hid between her cleavage. The recording will prove her innocent in self defense.
 
Fluttershy always makes sure that she brings a weapon and a tape recorder when she visits her dates homes for the first time. Sometimes distrust is good for your health, and Fluttershy knows this.
 
The End.

@Background Pony #780D  
I see. As for me, it’s because I’m a small, hideous troll of a hominin, and her liking me for reasons beyond genes or monetary intake is so utterly exotic to my thought patterns that it causes intense and paralyzing feelings of sheer terror.

@OneUglyDiamondDog  
I like her, but I already waifu someone else.

@Background Pony #780D  
Not a fan of Fluttershy?

 
Talk about a Morton’s fork. I’m scared I could hurt her if I reject her, but I also don’t want to give her (and others) the wrong idea by accepting.

This genuinely terrifies me.

@PonyPon  
Strange, didn’t show up when I searched for them…  
Oh, wait, they don’t have the bronybait tag, that’s why.

@Midnight Moon  
>>1141800  
>>1141799

What happened to the Twilight and Rainbow Dash version of these?

“I’m being really brace by even writing.”  
Way to pat yourself on the back. What do you want a cookie?

@Background Pony #CB86  
THESE WOUNDS THEY WILL NOT HEAL!

@Background Pony #93B9  
Well, I didn’t know that Ramsay Bolton was around here too…

@Background Pony #9852  
CRAAAAWWWLING IN MY SKIIIIIIN

Hmmm. Yes, Fluttershy. i want to be with you

NSFW/GRIMDARK||You read the letter, smiling as you realize that it has Fluttershy’s scent on it; sealing up the letter again, your smile slowly twists into an evil grin as you take a carpenter’s nail and impale the letter through the heart shaped sticker onto a corkboard, which has pictures of Fluttershy in various states of privacy and undress, a lock of her hair, a pair of her soiled panties, and documents of her schedule at the animal shelter for the next two weeks.
 
Oh yes, you’re very good with dogs, better with dogs than with people; indeed, you’ve always reversed it in your head. Dogs are loyal, dogs are determined; dogs won’t judge you on superficial bullshit like looks or surface personality traits. Dogs wouldn’t ignore your affections or make you feel like you were nothing.
 
You look over towards your collection of implements and knickknacks: your choking pear, your poisonous ballgag, your thumbscrews, your spiked Hitachi wand, and other such lovely tools of the trade, all engraved with that damn trio of butterflies you always associated with that stammering cunt. You laugh at the idea that you used to love her. Well, you still sort of love her…in your own special way.
 
You snap your fingers. Shamash! Marduk! Heel!
 
Your two pet bull mastiffs have been reared by hand since they were pups, and you love them like sons. And like any good father, it’s time for you to have the talk. You point in the direction of the doll, covered in Fluttershy’s scent, bodily fluids, and aphrodisiac; once you’ve blindfolded them they won’t be able to tell the difference.
 
Marduk! Collar! Shamash! Impale!
 
Marduk always had the stronger jaw, and Shamash always had the bigger knot, so it made sense for you to set it up like this as Marduk pins the Fluttershy effigy with his teeth to her throat and Shamash began to mount the doll, taking extra care to dig his claws into her ass as you trained.
 
Yes, you’re very good with dogs. And as Fluttershy will find out when you invite her over to your house and all her friends are out for the weekend…you’re very good with bitches, too.
 
Marduk. Kill.
 
Marduk closes his jaw, causing the practice bone in the neck to snap.
 
||

Who writes “uh”?

This is figging awesome!

Didn’t read the rest of the letter Fluttershy. You had me at hello.

>ANRGY  
really hope that didn’t make it into the final product