Rarishpee.

I’ve always Imagined Berry Punch with either a Scottish or Irish accent. Does that make me racist?

@YetAnotherBrony
 
“I have been in the wrong profession! I must learn this magic!”

@Background Pony #A99C
 
I like TwiMedic because MAD SCIENCE! (Seriously, she has a laboratory in her basement.)
 
That, and her questionable sanity. Not batshit insane like the Pyro or weird like the Soldier, somewhere in the middle.

@Krek
 
I like Twimedic. Medic’s skills are the closest any class gets to using magic.
 
Twilight Sniper never really made sense to me; it’s a mathematical class. So? Engineer is too. Demo makes his own bombs. Soldier, the dumbest of the bunch, made a rocket launcher from garbage. Clearly, they’re all intelligent for their particular fields.

@Shadow Star
 
I don’t think these make much sense either; doesn’t make them wrong.
 
Pinkie Pie is multitalented; the Pyro just burns things.  
Twilight is a wizard; the Sniper just shoots things.  
Fluttershy is an animal caretaker; the Medic is a butcher and a mad scientist who considers healing a side-effect of his actual experiments  
Zecora is a medicine mare; the Demo is a bomb-maker.
 
Twilight would just as easily be Engineer or Medic (the two smartest classes), Applejack seems more the ‘strong, head on’ type (maybe Soldier or Demo), Pinkie is alot more fitted for a class that does more than one thing (maybe Soldier), Zecora seems like Medic’d be the only class for her, and Fluttershy is likely to play a class that actively tries to avoid battle (sniper or spy).
 
That’s just how I view it though.

@Dumb Rock  
Well, i prefer pinkie as pyro, because of the pyro’s behavior, like, did you whatch the Meet the pyro video?  
That pyroland, that other personality, its just like pinkie.  
Just because spike can use fire, does’t mean he is pyro, if you play with pyro a lot, you will see that other “personality”

Fluttermeem

@Krek
 
And for being truly sciency. Zecora can work too, she knows a lot about healing and medicine.

I still prefer Metal Kitty’s version.

@Dumb Rock  
Makes some sense.
 
With that in mind, perhaps Twilight could be the Medic, due to some of her “crazier” moments.

@Krek
 
Agreed. Both Spike an the Pyro use fire, and Spychecking is a good analogue for Spike’s crush on Rarity. Pinkie and the Soldier are both crazy and loud.
 
I also prefer Fluttershy as the Sniper, because they are both nature-oriented and isolated. I’ve always found Fluttershy’s relation to the Medic flimsy.

I completly agree with the entire layout

@Krek  
“C’mere, cupcake”

I think Spike would make for a better Pyro than Pinkie would.
 
In fact, Pinkie would make a better Soldier, IMO.

Apple Bloom as Engineer  
Scootaloo as Scout  
Sweetie Belle as Spy

@Dreamsicle  
I would say:
 
Bulk Biceps as Heavy  
Braeburn as Engineer  
Soarin as Scout  
Dr. Stable as Medic  
Cheese Sandwich as Pyro  
Hoity Toity as Spy  
One of the Diamond Dogs as Demo  
Maud Pie as Sniper  
Shining Armor as Soldeir

@D4RKM4NOLO  
I dunno. Some artists made a whole alternative lineup for BLU. Like Nurse Redheart as the Medic.

@Dreamsicle  
Well, like tf2, I think the BLU team is the same charactera, just with a diferent color, and by the way, i can change their colors on SFM too, they have a BLU skin!

I wonder who their BLU team equivalents would be.

I love seeing ponies in “people clothes,” it’s to cute.
 
The Rarity is a spy.

no, there are just ones that make no sense.

@Background Pony #32E1  
Uh, yeah, i guess?  
I just found the modelo of each one, and I really like derpy as soldier, is so , perfect!

@Shadow Star  
Because there is one perfect, uncontradictible, true headcanon and everyone who thinks differently is wrong, right?…

thumbs up for getting whos what right.