Well I finally watched the Pinocchio remake, and unfortunately I have mixed feelings towards this one.
I try to give these remakes the benefit of the doubt, I understand peoples complaints towards them being pointless in their existence (not that it’s gonna change anything honestly) but I like to see different interpretations of stories we are familiar with especially if it can be done well and be meaningful which is why I watch them first then judge after, and out of all the remakes I’ve seen the only ones I truely hated were Maleficent, The Lion King, and Mulan so personally I don’t see a lot of them as awful.
Now when it was announced there would be a live action Pinocchio, I got excited since that is one of my top favorite Disney films of all time and hopefully like The Jungle Book it would on par with the original.
Well there are somethings I liked that were an improvement over the original, but sadly this is one of those cases where the remake just couldn’t compete.
The things I liked about the film were most of the cast, Pinocchio was good and did well capturing the original, Tom Hanks as Geppetto was good, Joseph Gordon-Levitt as Jiminy Cricket I liked, Keegan Michael Key as Honest John I really liked and wished he was in it more, and the puppeteer woman with the ballerina marionette I didn’t mind and her relationship with Pinocchio was kinda cute.
There were things in the story that were added that I liked, such as Geppetto having a son who he lost so the wooden puppet was made as a means for comfort, he also doesn’t send Pinocchio to school immediately the next day but rather home schooled him for a while before finally letting him, and also adding in an explanation for why he went out at sea searching for him.
There’s also some little moments I liked such as Geppetto’s clocks being based off of various Disney characters, and when Pinocchio gets donkey ears and a tail they actually look like they’re made of wood and built to be apart of him.
With that said the rest of the movie I have problems with, like the story adding in too much filler to the story needlessly dragging out the runtime, a lot of the characters are not as good as the original and the new characters added in (like the talking seagull) I found to not be good or entertaining, music numbers are okay and I’m glad they brought back most of them but the new ones aren’t very good and feel unnecessary, special effects look fine but could have been a lot better and maybe not rely too heavily on the CGI for a lot of it, and then there are a few minor things I felt were not needed (Like Pinocchio needing to examine horse feces).
I will say what they did with Monstro the whale is both kinda cool but baffling beyond belief where they decided to give him monster tentacles like he’s Cthulhu or something.
And finally there’s the ending ||in which they left it sorta open ended in case they try to make a sequel, so in other words Pinocchio doesn’t actually become a real boy at the end which kinda defeats the purpose of this movie’s existence. ||
My final vertic: 5/10, watch the original instead.