So, The highly divisive EARN IT Act was just introduced aaannnnd I have mixed feelings in all honesty
We already know it’s bipartisan and we already know it’s issues so we know what to expect, I don’t think this is quite an “Internet Ending” bill like A17 or SOPA as it doesn’t target average things like copyright, fanfics, and small sites the government doesn’t give a shit about as it’s main target is online crime. I think the best comparisons are Australia’s 2018 encryption law, Germany and France’s hate speech laws, and FOSTA/SESTA, All of which are plagued with issues.
Plus I don’t actually hate the proposal, I do think tech companies should be held accountable for the most heinous crimes on their sites like exploitation, But the risk about encryption is the main issue that most critics of the bill have and they do have valid points like undermining encryption would cause a lot of privacy issues and possible over-censoring like what happened with FOSTA/SESTA. While it being bipartisan isn’t exactly great, It’s also not that bad of a thing as that indicates that congress is genuinely trying to do some good in my opinion, But if it were partisan, that would indicate that the proposal actually has malicious intents like censoring content said party doesn’t like, But luckily that’s not the case. Overall it’s a mixed bag but I’m not gonna panic about it unless it’s 100% necessary because I really don’t want to get involved with “moderate” Internet threats like this one as the depression I’ve had since A17 passed last year really took an emotional toll on me.
Update: Bill has pushback from Republicans,
And some Democrats as well. This means that the bill is gonna have significant obstacles to get through.