Rating tags general

A thread for just the rating tags so General Tag Discussion doesn’t get mired.
 
General reminder:  

I approve of this. Sticking it for now, if another staff member disagrees, they can remove it.

I think this is a fantastic idea. @LightningBolt - Thank you for sticking it.

@saby  
When in doubt, don’t change rating at all; hasty ratings changes are a big source of tagwarring, and images rated too high can piss off artists (or cosplayers) greatly because you’re accusing them of sexual intent if you don’t have something solid to base the rating off of.

@Princess Luna  
Yeah I didn’t mean that as in changing tags but tagging a new upload. Tried to make it clearer.

@Princess Luna  
@saby  
But, we can still discuss them here, and if they merit any change, right?

@Zaknel  
Of course, it’s just that it’s best to discuss when in doubt, instead of change right away.

It could be my eyes playing tricks on me, but I think I saw a nipple outline in this image.
 

 
Does that make it ‘suggestive’, in that case? Or, am I seeing things? I am willing to admit to it being my fault, but I wanna make sure.

@Zaknel  
That’s a difference of the jiggling of segments of the curve, and if it were a nipple, it’d be massive, so no.

Is it considered ‘suggestive’ or more to show a character peeing graphically? Is it considered ‘suggestive’ or more to visually request someone to drink pee?

@Zaknel  
Depends on whether it’s a sexualized context; if so, questionable for the former and suggestive for the latter, but otherwise, both are safe (not that it’s very common to be requesting someone drink pee for innocent reasons).

@Princess Luna  
So, should this be ‘suggestive’, ‘questionable’ or neither? Because, in the show, I’ve never seen them introduce such bodily fluids.
 

 
It just kind of stuck out to me that that was rated ‘safe’, because I never thought that such an image would be.

@Zaknel  
It’s in the same vein as “You’re a cunt.” being safe-rated; the show wouldn’t go there, but not for sexual reasons, and we don’t have a corresponding rating for vulgarity/offensiveness.

should this get a grotesque rating?  

@StrangeGirl  
It’s close, but I think the way the guts are coming out near the ribcage puts it over the line, yes.

@Princess Luna  
We have “vulgar”, “slur”, and for more lurid textual non-safeness, upcoming “verbal abuse”.

@saby  
Those aren’t ratings, however.

Featureless breasts are safe when not sexualized and suggestive if they are sexualized, correct?

@mav  
I suppose, but they would usually be suggestive for emphasis of some kind unless they’re out of the way.

@Princess Luna  
i see, thanks.

@Meanlucario  
Hmm, very interesting edge case. I’m thinking it’s just barely safe because it’s imitating the suggestive hair-over-nipples look but with actual clothing over everything; it’s definitely on the borderline either way.

@Princess Luna  
OK than, thanks.

Safe or suggestive?
 

 
It’s tagged as safe so I’m not sure.

@TheMultiBrony21  
i would say suggestive?