LightningBolt 
![Thread Starter - [NO SPOILER, LEAK-FREE] Season 8 Discussion and Speculation: Discovery Family airings](https://derpicdn.net/badges/2017/7/2/0bd59d4eff9c3aeaad.svg "Thread Starter - [NO SPOILER, LEAK-FREE] Season 8 Discussion and Speculation: Discovery Family airings")
Senior Moderator
Undead inside
Okay there seems to be some confusion on how
Undeniably, these are all sirens, no one would debate they aren’t, and the tag applies to them 100%. It also applies to redesigns of sirens that follow the same beats, like the few below.
Now for the tricky part, are these sirens?
If you looked at their tags, you’ll see that they are tagged
Now for the tricky part, are these sirens?
They are currently tagged as such, so are they? They don’t look much like them, but are meant to be, and have some design elements that hint at it, notably fin ears, eyes, and fangs. But half-sirens look more like sirens than these. Maybe a
What about these?
The first one is tagged
And for one last tag,
A character who is naturally a
So, the
As a bonus, a siren, a sea pony, and a seapony.
siren should be tagged here, and I often see people add them to unapplying images and removing them from those that do apply, so, let’s make some things clear.
Undeniably, these are all sirens, no one would debate they aren’t, and the tag applies to them 100%. It also applies to redesigns of sirens that follow the same beats, like the few below.
Now for the tricky part, are these sirens?
If you looked at their tags, you’ll see that they are tagged
half-siren and not siren, the other half is pony, this is for more pony-looking sirens with four legs and a fish tail, kind of like shark ponies I suppose. Good for offspring, hybrids, and just more pony-like variations.Now for the tricky part, are these sirens?
>>
They are currently tagged as such, so are they? They don’t look much like them, but are meant to be, and have some design elements that hint at it, notably fin ears, eyes, and fangs. But half-sirens look more like sirens than these. Maybe a
half-siren (EQG) tag would be better?What about these?
The first one is tagged
siren, but the latter two are tagged mermaid instead and used to be tagged siren. Does mermaid apply to the latter two better? Or should it be siren instead, or in addition to, for those?And for one last tag,
disguised siren. 
A character who is naturally a
siren, but is currently seen in a different form. This tag would theoretically apply to any depiction of a siren character in a different shape from, well, being a siren.So, the
siren tag is a bit of a mess, and tags connected to it a bit of a mess as well.As a bonus, a siren, a sea pony, and a seapony.
