@Pagan  
Nope, I didn’t, I couldn’t have, I didn’t make this image.

Option 2 has no hooves so it’s option one for me.

Huh, it’s easy. Both.

Pony pet flutters because OP didn’t factor in for the beastiality that will happen.

I want to touch that mane, so pet it is.  
but that will never happen

Sunset Shimmer, Twilight Sparkle, or Rarity as my girlfriend, and Human Fluttershy as my pet.

The latter, duh.

Don’t make me choose, I WANT THEM BOTH.

If I play my cards right, I can have both. I’ll go with option A.

Pet, pet. With her on my side I can have any gf I want!