I pick Twilight Sparkle.

Solution: get in the middle and have ALL of them hug me. But Applejack gets first hug.

No contest. I’ll take Twilight. We can spend time together and try to come up with a way to bring the others through to our side of the door. It’ll be difficult to work out before New Year, but I’m sure we can work something out between the two of us.

Twilight! She needs the hugs!

Applejack! No… Twilight! No… Fluttershy! No… All three… ?

Pinkie Pie!
 
Nonono wait!,Fluttershy!
 
But…Rarity..
 
…Twi-…
 
DAMMIT!, I CANT TAKE JUST ONE!

I’ll take Pinkie. She makes everything fun.

Can I wait until next year, so I can have the pony until 2014?

I can’t pick. Not when they’re looking like that. To Tartarus with your rules, CS. I’ll hug all of them and you can’t stop me.

Pinkie

“I’ll take the one in the middle!”  
“which one?”  
“I’LL TAKE THE ONE IN THE MIDDLE!!!”

Rainbow Dash.

I’ll take Twilight Sparkle.

I don’t see why you are always making us choose CS, especially since I will always choose Fluttershy.

Fluttershy. I ship her with my OC in my AU.

Fluttershy would be soft, I pick her.

I’d pick Pinkie so that she would break the rules of this picture and let me hug the rest as well.

It is always interesting how these things turn out. Way more Rarity than I was expecting.
 
I of course would pick Rainbow Dash because that means I would get to spend time with Rainbow Dash.

fluttershy fo sho

I choose AppleRariFlutterRaibowSparklePie! Er, but in all seriousness, probably Applejack.

I don’t see derpy >:|

I CHOOSE YOU, FLUTTERCHU!

ALL OF THEM, BUT PINKIE IN PARTICULAR.

If I HAVE to choose one… hugs Pinkie