rainbowdash42
…how does your implication hold? There’s even a bit after the incompetent coronation where they all come together and resolve to remain friends. That’s the whole reason for the Council.
The episode implies that the friends broke up in the first and second acts precisely to lead on the viewer, until the reveal. This is a very common storytelling tactic, particularly in episodes told like this one. Heck, I think a similar strategy was even used in the Snowfall Frost episode (I don’t care to read the whole transcript to find it, sorry).
And if you listen to the characters’ explanations as to why they weren’t acting worried about losing their friendship, they were just trying to cover it up or be strong, for Twilight’s sake. You can argue that this point was poorly written, but it’s right there in the text:
Again, with all due respect, I think you’re (intentionally or not) twisting the episode to your own ends. Occam’s Razor – the simplest explanation is usually the best one. And the simplest explanation is to take the episode at face value.
Oh cool, I didn’t know we could conjure events in and out of existence.
Does that mean that if I wish really hard, S10E01 will premiere on Saturday?
Does that mean that if I wish really hard, S10E01 will premiere on Saturday?
Luster Dawn: So, even though everything changed and you moved away from your friends, you didn’t grow apart? And this is the Council of Friendship? That’s what you’re all doing here?
Future Rainbow Dash: Duh! This time every moon.
Future Applejack: [chuckles] What she means is this is how we’ve been rulin’ together.
Future Rarity: And how we’ve continued to face every problem and threat to Equestria over the years.
Future Pinkie Pie: But mostly, it’s how we keep in touch. No matter how busy life gets.
Future Twilight Sparkle: Sometimes friendships can be hard, and it takes work to maintain them. But without friends, things can be a lot harder.
…how does your implication hold? There’s even a bit after the incompetent coronation where they all come together and resolve to remain friends. That’s the whole reason for the Council.
The episode implies that the friends broke up in the first and second acts precisely to lead on the viewer, until the reveal. This is a very common storytelling tactic, particularly in episodes told like this one. Heck, I think a similar strategy was even used in the Snowfall Frost episode (I don’t care to read the whole transcript to find it, sorry).
And if you listen to the characters’ explanations as to why they weren’t acting worried about losing their friendship, they were just trying to cover it up or be strong, for Twilight’s sake. You can argue that this point was poorly written, but it’s right there in the text:
Twilight Sparkle: I tried to talk to you all about how I was feeling, but you seemed more worried about what you had to do for the coronation.
Spike: It’s true. I was there.
Rarity: I suppose it gave us something else to focus on.
Applejack: I knew you were worried about everything changin’. I guess I thought if I made it seem like everything was okay, it would be.
Fluttershy: I was just trying to make you feel better. That way I wouldn’t feel so terrible.
Again, with all due respect, I think you’re (intentionally or not) twisting the episode to your own ends. Occam’s Razor – the simplest explanation is usually the best one. And the simplest explanation is to take the episode at face value.