Harshie83
Live from the hive
I should probably rephrase that comment lol.
They might look at being turned to stone as a regular, severe punishment.
They might look at being turned to stone as a regular, severe punishment.
There was nothing stopping them from Simply crying out “we surrender”!
They did with cozy glow. And no, her faking it doesn’t nullify the fact that they made genuine efforts to be nice to her.
Excuse you?“Learn to be fair”?You just said that they “still had no reason to like the ponies who threw them away all the while.”Last I checked, they went out of their way to make the ponies lives miserable. So exactly what right do they have to be angry when they get thrown away? Sounds like you’re the one who needs to learn to be fair.
Considering the fact that she made it clear that she didn’t WANT to be properly known, she dug her own grave there. Besides, she’s the one who entered the school of friendship just for the exact opposite reasons.
Did he honestly expect no repercussions for his own actions?
I’d say it’s more on you considering the fact that they were willing to accept Scorpan, they might have accepted Tirek if he actually put in the effort. But he was more content with draining their livelihood and enslaving them.Given his personality and attitude and lust for power? It’s obvious that he didn’t.
Funny you talk about learning empathy despite the villains you’re standing up for showcasing none.
Considering the fact that they still have the elements and yet one of them genuinely agreed to not use them against him. He had basically got in free rein and yet was able to real himself in. So, Yeah.
Chrysalis claimed that. Tirek and Cozy looked scared, right up until they got stoned.It would have been a perfect time to reach out to them.
Unfortunately, Twilight and her friends never appealed to it.
They were straight-up talked out of it and still had no reason to like the ponies who threw them away all the while.Learn to be fair, and stop acting like that was a fair shot.
And so she didn’t learn anything. Once that’s clear it’s time to correct that and get to actually know Cozy. Or toss the child into hell and forget about it. That’s something a school of FRIENDSHIP should be doing, right?
And Scorpan just let it happen after helping him get caught. And you honestly expect Tirek to learn anything other than hate through this?
How do you know he did? Nothing ever says that, so the burden of proof is on you.
I suggest you learn a little empathy and how to more properly read a situation.
“Same chances?” That’s an honest laugh.
No it doesn’t, because he got the same chance, when he was brought back. He had a chance to see what it was like to actually genuinely befriend someone. The trio have that in the sense that they befriended each other, but dismissed it outright.Congratulations, your argument is dead in the water.
And those different circumstances are that they put a lot of effort into reforming Discord. That’s it.
Their reformation doesn’t exist. None of the things you’re citing as their second chance actually involved the ponies being aware of what was going on or an honest effort to reform them.
Discord made it clear he didn’t want to change. Why did they still try hard to change him then?
No, you keep interpreting scraps as chances. Cozy and Tirek clearly show that friendship CAN change them,
If I go into a school all about Spanish with no intention of learning Spanish, then I’m not going to learn any Spanish even if it’s written on the fliers.
You’re not going to learn something without the proper desire to learn and good instruction based on what kind of person you are.
If Scorpan cared you’d think he’d at least bargain to get Tirek a punishment that WASN’T Tarturs for all eternity after betraying him. It’s no wonder Tirek hates them all and he has no reason not to.
If they want Tirek to change, then be his friend. It’s that simple. Don’t talk about your friends.
Pointing out bad and hypocritical writing isn’t whining. Sorry if you think it is.The fact that you can’t see the clear differences between an honest reformation attempt and circumstantial second thoughts in a horrible situation is sad.
You do realize that if Discord got the same “chances” Cozy, Tirek, and even Chrysalis got, he’d still be evil. Right?That kills your argument right there.
I can because those are different circumstances.
Not every reformation is exactly the same, the trio made it clear that they didn’t want to change.
After they made it clear that they would never change? And as I said before, they were given their chances. And they swatted them away.
It counts because the main reason she was there was to study friendship. It doesn’t matter if he was faking it, if she’s going to just use them as a means to an end, why should they give her the benefit of the doubt?
They managed to give his brother a better outlook on life, he’s the one who decided to reject it entirely, that’s his fault, not theirs.
It’s fair because at the end the circumstances allow him to see the benefits of friendship properly, the villains Neil had those circumstances but rejected them anyway.They had their chance and they blew it, deal with it and stop whining.