I think Greg Cipes should voice male Scootaloo actually

Zach Callison, I think, would be a better voice choice for colt Sweetie Bell actually

On second thought, I think Jack McBrayer should be the voice of male Applejack, Richard Ian Cox as Bubble Berry, and Samuel Vincent as Butterscotch. Sorry, I can’t make up my mind.

I also forgot to delete an extra comma

Oops, I forgot to delete the second “both” in that comment

Actually, I think both Bubble Berry and Butterscotch, should be both voiced by Daniel Brochu. He’s the guy that voiced Buster Baxter from Arthur.

My voice choices:
 
Jason Marsden - Dusk Shine, Rainbow Blitz, and Brad Seed (I prefer this name for male Babs Seed rather than Bob Steed)  
James Arnold Taylor - Applejack  
Vincent Tong - Elusive  
Daniel Brochu - Bubble Berry  
Samuel Vincent - Butterscotch  
Atticus Shaffer - Silver Bell  
Kyle Rideout - Scooteroll  
Lucas Grabeel - Applebuck

I can’t help but think that Silver/Sweepy Bell should be Ian Corlett.

did somebody say…Tim Curry?  

tim curry as elusive that makes perfect sence

I have a better idea  
Scooteroll – Jeremy Shada  
AppleBuck and Bab Seed – Logan Grove  
Silver Bell – Kweski Boakye  
Jeremy voices Finn, Logan voices Gumball the blue cat, and Kewski voices Darwin the goldfish.

I figured Crispin Freeman would be better for Elusive; he’d be able to pull of “Suave” in his sleep. As for Dusk, I’d honestly pull for Brad Swaille. Johnny Yong Bosch has done enough shy characters to fill Butterscotch easily, while still leaving room for his more badass phases. Maxey Whitehead for Silver Bell, Spike Spencer for Bob Seed, and Yuri Lowenthal for Applebuck.

Butterscotch voice by Kiefer Sutherland

Please, how could you chose anyone But Stephen Fry for Elusive?
 
I’d also like to add Sylvester McCoy for Solaris.

I hear Elusive as Jon H Benjamin

Butterscotch voice by Jason Statham.

@Princess♠Molestia
 
“Farming. Farming never changes.”

@Background Pony  
Cut it. Just give a role, and I’ll might consider it.

“Dave Wittenberg” is how you spell the name of the voice actor behind Dusk Shine.

@ClownDicks  
Berry, Blitz, AJ, and Scooterroll is Ravie.  
Elusive, and Dusk is Celestia Redux.

@CloSeph  
You know Applebuck is a foal right?

What font is this?

@DashingJack  
Hellboy

@Princess♠Molestia  
I don’t know. Give me a role he was in.

INB4 Smashing!