diabeetus

@Background Pony #4244  
The cutie mark of herself really kinda pushes it over the line into “this is a parody isn’t it” territory.
 
It’s like freaking Homestar Runner pony.

yeah, right.  
I mean Mrs Cake or the puppetmaster in »Inspiration Manifestation«, no problem.  
But THIS! NO!  
Looks like a very bad or mocking OC.  
She’s not fat, she is I don’t no what.  
The ugly mane.  
And her face is her Cutie Mark, really?  
Who is responsible for this pony?

@Background Pony #B2CA  
Gabriel Iglesias calls it DAMN!

She’ not fat. We have to invent a new wort for that was she is. She’s “physically impossible”.

Less “fat” and more “what is wrong with your proportions you look like some kind of weird freakish giant.”

Fat? Try morbidly obese.

Mrs. Cake is a mother of two, that’s her excuse for being the way she is.

…oh! I bet this is the look of a pony with the Luna/Fleur-de-Lis body model that gets obese.
 
And yeah, the yellow eyes mean she might have a metabolic problem; liver or something.

@Marusame  
agreed the design looks terrible. They could have just used the same design model as the puppeteer guy and made is a mare. She would still be a big mare, but look nice. This looks out of place.

there have been plenty of bigger ponies and they looked fine. The puppet guy from that rarity episode when she got the spellbook. Or the big dude from the ponytones thing with the daughter zipperwits. But that character design seemed just a bit far out of place in many ways.

I say “obese”  
The puppeteer from “Inspiration manifestation” was fat

@Kamazeustra  
Not really. I’d say that I’m about as big in human terms as that Roseluck is in pony terms. Apart from the occasional twinge here or there in a joint, I’m all right doing day to day stuff. Except when I have to run to catch the bus. xD

@Yet_One_More_Idiot  
No, that Roseluck is still likely to have health problems. If not for that belt cinching her gut she’d be Garfield during this arc.
 

@Background Pony #AC15  
I wouldn’t do either of them. Mrs Cake, because she’s happily married and I’m not a homewrecking b*****, and the other pone because I wouldn’t want her to die from the over-exertion. xD
 
Now, as for >>969503, chubby Roseluck…yeah, she’s nice and cute and kinda big, but not quite so big that I’d be really worried about her health.

@Background Pony #AC15  
Exactly.

Difference is I’d splooge inside Ms. Cake but not the other pony.

Is this how larson pictures a fat pony?  
This is fat pony  

@SocDev  

@Lupin Quill  
*OP

But anon, as the tags will tell you, chubby implies fat!

This pony is suffering from liver problems…

left good, right… bluargh.

This is going places.

If Mrs Cake is “chubby”, then I’m the pope!
 
The second one is not just obese, she’s a heart-attack waiting to happen.