Rainbow Rocks 10th Anniversary - Let's celebrate the 10th anniversary of Rainbow Rocks with an art event! Here

Viewing last 25 versions of comment by Dale on image #1123849

Dale
The End wasn't The End - Found a new home after the great exodus of 2012

"[@Background Pony #52D6":](/1123849#comment_4893458

)
 
No, a _*near_*-official agreement. Important distinction. The producers, writers (including novel and comic book writers), actors, and fans all agreed on a common stance of 'oh jesus, _*Threshold_*, let's not'. Paramount never said shit. It's just that _*Threshold_* was so bad that the show people involved wish it didn't exist. If MLP throws an episode that the showrunners regret that badly, the fandom might come to the same agreement.


 
What Hasbro says and what Hasbro does are two separate things. Star Trek's Alpha/Beta split is not an official stance from Paramount, it's a fan construction to agree how to interpret contradictory stuff. They talk a big talk about everything being canon because they want everyone to buy everything, but in practice, the show is not being required to subordinate itself to any other media, and all other media may be invalidated by the show at any moment. That is a two-tiered canon structure.
Reason: Minor tense edit.
Edited by Dale
Dale
The End wasn't The End - Found a new home after the great exodus of 2012

"@Background Pony #52D6":/1123849#comment_4893458

No, a _near_-official agreement. Important distinction. The producers, writers (including novel and comic book writers), actors, and fans all agreed on a common stance of 'oh jesus, _Threshold_, let's not'. Paramount never said shit. It's just that _Threshold_ was so bad that the show people involved wish it didn't exist. If MLP throws an episode that the showrunners regret that badly, the fandom might come to the same agreement.

What Hasbro says and what Hasbro does are two separate things. Star Trek's Alpha/Beta split is not an official stance from Paramount, it's a fan construction to agree how to interpret contradictory stuff. They talk a big talk about everything being canon because they want everyone to buy everything, but in practice, the show is not being required to subordinate itself to any other media, and all other media may be invalidated by the show at any moment. That is a two-tiered canon structure.
No reason given
Edited by Dale