Viewing last 25 versions of comment by BackgroundLoL on image #1406252

Celestia is here curiously behaving very similar to how the IDW comic presented Sunset Shimmer...
 
>>458736p
 
>>458738p


 
To be fair though, that presentation had it's flaws, as it made out Sunset quite vicious even in the past, as well as somewhat 2-dimensional (contradicting the fact even in the first movie, there suggested depth to Sunset, with her saying she doesn't know anything about friendship, and herfeeling replaced by Twilight).


 
Not to mention, the comic was latter was pretty much erased by contradictions from the main canon, Sunset saying in _*Rainbow Rocks_*, she had doubts about her evil actions, just pushed those doubts back, while the comic didn't show it all. Canon also with a very different Moondancer, and her, Lemon Hearts, Congate, and Twinkleshine were presented as Twilight's age, were in the comic Twilight is much younger.


 
I can appreciate IDW trying to be consistent with their previous work, by having young Celestia behave like younger Sunset Shimmer in their version, but the Sunset Shimmer comic, wasn't exactly good, with a **ton** of wasted piotential, and this comic, contradicts **everything** that was previously shown about young Celestia, like in the _*The Journal of the Two Sisters_*.


 
Not to mention, with such charater derliment, it adds to the Celestia hate.

Celestia is here curiously behaving very similar to how the IDW comic presented Sunset Shimmer...
>>458736p
>>458738p

To be fair though, that presentation had it's flaws, as it made out Sunset quite vicious even in the past, as well as somewhat 2-dimensional (contradicting the fact even in the first movie, there suggested depth to Sunset, with her saying she doesn't know anything about friendship, and herfeeling replaced by Twilight).

Not to mention, the comic was latter was pretty much erased by contradictions from the main canon, Sunset saying in _Rainbow Rocks_, she had doubts about her evil actions, just pushed those doubts back, while the comic didn't show it all. Canon also with a very different Moondancer, and her, Lemon Hearts, Congate, and Twinkleshine were presented as Twilight's age, were in the comic Twilight is much younger.

I can appreciate IDW trying to be consistent with their previous work, by having young Celestia behave like younger Sunset Shimmer in their version, but the Sunset Shimmer comic, wasn't exactly good, with a *ton* of wasted pitential, and this comic, contradicts *everything* that was previously shown about young Celestia, like in the _The Journal of the Two Sisters_.

Not to mention, with such charater derliment, it adds to the Celestia hate.

Celestia is here curiously behaving very similar to how the IDW comic presented Sunset Shimmer...
>>458736p
>>458738p

To be fair though, that presentation had it's flaws, as it made out Sunset quite vicious even in the past, as well as somewhat 2-dimensional (contradicting the fact even in the first movie, there suggested depth to Sunset, with her saying she doesn't know anything about friendship, and herfeeling replaced by Twilight).

Not to mention, the comic was latter was pretty much erased by contradictions from the main canon, Sunset saying in _Rainbow Rocks_, she had doubts about her evil actions, just pushed those doubts back, while the comic didn't show it all. Canon also with a very different Moondancer, and her, Lemon Hearts, Congate, and Twinkleshine were presented as Twilight's age, were in the comic Twilight is much younger.

I can appreciate IDW trying to be consistent with their previous work, but the Sunset Shimmer comic, wasn't exactly good, with a *ton* of wasted pitential, and this comic, contradicts *everything* that was previously shown about young Celestia, like in the _The Journal of the Two Sisters_.

Not to mention, with such charater derliment, it adds to the Celestia hate.

Celestia is here curiously behaving very similar to how the IDW comic presented Sunset Shimmer...
>>458736p
>>458738p

To be fair though, that presentation had it's flaws, as it made out Sunset quite vicious, as well as somewhat 2-dimensional (contradicting the fact even in the first movie, there suggested depth to Sunset, with her saying she doesn't know anything about friendship, and herfeeling replaced by Twilight).

Not to mention, the comic was latter was pretty much erased by contradictions from the main canon, Sunset saying in _Rainbow Rocks_, she had doubts about her evil actions, just pushed those doubts back, while the comic didn't show it all. Canon also with a very different Moondancer, and her, Lemon Hearts, Congate, and Twinkleshine were presented as Twilight's age, were in the comic Twilight is much younger.

I can appreciate IDW trying to be consistent with their previous work, but the Sunset Shimmer comic, wasn't exactly good, with a *ton* of wasted pitential, and this comic, contradicts*everything* that was previously shown about young Celestia, like in the _The Journal of the Two Sisters_.

Not to mention, with such charater derliment, it adds to the Celestia hate.