Rainbow Rocks 10th Anniversary - Let's celebrate the 10th anniversary of Rainbow Rocks with an art event! Here

Viewing last 25 versions of comment by Background Pony #A65F on image #808254

Background Pony #A65F
Fall of Equestria, ok, there are people who like this type of crap as a fetish, I think we all get that... However, People don't bash on it because of the art or because of it simply existing... We bash on it because its autistic fanbase takes its concept soo seriously, they think it's good material for stories, and that's the problem. It is not good material, the factions are extremely unbalanced and the villains are Mary Sues. Seriously, magic immunity!? Out of fucking nowhere!? In a world that has every living being rely on mana!?


 
Ok, they could have gone with the caribou having strong resistance to a limited degree, but no, straight up immune juggernauts just cause. If you're going to make a story, do it right. Fucking nerf the caribou, and don't give us that crystal heart/cock bullshit, that was pulled out of the fandom's ass. There is no evidence that shows the crystal heart has mind altering capabilities! If you're going to give us a bullshit plot miguffin, make it original and don't screwed over the already established physics for the world your basing it on. It's like one of those shitty crossovers where you just mash the physics together to a point where nothing makes sense.


 
Also, give the heroes a fighting chance, or even give the story alternate outcomes for each scenario so there is some sort of happy ending people can enjoy or a silver linning. It's terrible as a story because it's only about Mary Sues walking into Equestria saying they own the place just cause they say so, and that's it.


 
And you make all stallions look like they crave for ||sex|| or are extremely weak minded for no reason. I hate the story because it thinks it's a legitimate story, plain and simple. The fans need to get their crap together and smell the fresh air of actual writing skills if they want to redeem this steaming pile of sexist, segregational, biased dogshit.
Reason: Rule #0/7
Edited by TheLoneLampman
Background Pony #A65F
Fall of Equestria, ok, there are people who like this type of crap as a fetish, I think we all get that... However, People don't bash on it because of the art or because of it simply existing... We bash on it because its autistic fanbase takes its concept soo seriously, they think it's good material for stories, and that's the problem. It is not good material, the factions are extremely unbalanced and the villains are Mary Sues. Seriously, magic immunity!? Out of fucking nowhere!? In a world that has every living being rely on mana!?

Ok, they could have gone with the caribou having strong resistance to a limited degree, but no, straight up immune juggernauts just cause. If you're going to make a story, do it right. Fucking nerf the caribou, and don't give us that crystal heart/cock bullshit, that was pulled out of the fandom's ass. There is no evidence that shows the crystal heart has mind altering capabilities! If you're going to give us a bullshit plot miguffin, make it original and don't screwed over the already established physics for the world your basing it on. It's like one of those shitty crossovers where you just mash the physics together to a point where nothing makes sense.

Also, give the heroes a fighting chance, or even give the story alternate outcomes for each scenario so there is some sort of happy ending people can enjoy or a silver linning. It's terrible as a story because it's only about Mary Sues walking into Equestria saying they own the place just cause they say so, and that's it.

And you make all stallions look like they crave for sex or are extremely weak minded for no reason. I hate the story because it thinks it's a legitimate story, plain and simple. The fans need to get their crap together and smell the fresh air of actual writing skills if they want to redeem this steaming pile of sexist, segregational, biased dogshit.
No reason given
Edited by TheLoneLampman