In all honesty, I gotta go with Superior.
 
They may not be as big, but they’re just the right size in my eyes.

Super superior please

@odiz  
I am confused.

thighs of super superior, but chest of superior

@Background Pony  
FATAL is a tabletop RPG that has some… odd rules.  
You can look it up if you’re interested in knowing them and reading a 900 page long (literally) rulebook.
 
@odiz  
I’m having fun with it as well and don’t treat it seriously by any streach of imagination.
 
I thought the one on the left was ridiculous (and you said you planned to make it ridiculous) so i brought up FATAL where your ridiculous is actually the “perfect looking female”… well minus the abs.

@odiz  
Or maybe people just have a different sense of humour than you.

@The_Mungoman
 
because she super superior applebucking thighs ?

look im trying i have a some  
fun with this pic here.
 
and have a sense of humor about it,  
or have some people forgot how  
to LOL?

@odiz  
So why the heck would you call her “super superior”?

@Sonlirain  
@Background Pony
 
look.. the one on the left was  
meant to be a joke pic.  
on how ridiculous it  
can be.
 
the one on the right is  
the original real piece.
 
Personally i go with the one on the right.

@Sonlirain  
You have odd definitions of “perfect”.

@Background Pony  
Assuming everything Odiz uploads was made by him then… well i have no idea if those are design decisions or flaws but i think there are better things to rage on.
 
Personally i think the “superior” mode has some issues like the giant tighs (how they are connected is imo a non issue as long as it’s not totally ridiculous due to the cartoony nature of the picture).
 
The “super superior” one belongs in the FATAL.PDF as an example of a perfect female.

@Sonlirain  
Look at his other pictures then, and tell me that they don’t look a little… deformed.

@Tenafly Viper  
I don’t think he even wanted to make them look “realistic” it was a design choice and just based the anatomy on EQG toys.

@odiz  
It’s too bad that I don’t have a gif for “butthurt alert”.
 
Sorry, but no - this artist has no concept of how female anatomy actually goes together.

@odiz  
That is… grossly irrelevant.

the jacky on the left just trying to  
channel her inner ivy.  

Tenafly Viper’s quote  
“Does this artist not know what “hips” are?”
 
(Insult Detection Warning !)  
 
(Insult Detection Warning !)
 
try to say calm….  

 
(Deep Breathing)..ok..
 
i guess some people just don’t get it.
 

They’re both terrible. Does this artist not know what “hips” are?
 
Unless they were purposefully going by the Equestria Girls toys, which cheaply have the legs directly attached to the torso, this is not how female anatomy works. Hips are not optional.

@FanOfMostEverything  
I think they both have the same size torsos actually. Only thing I prefer about the one on the left is the thighs are a li’l bigger. (I like bigger thighs then I do bigger boobs honestly.)
 
The abs look kinda weird to.

@LightDark  
think because they’re trying a super hero type episode

@Sonlirain  
Ah, but what’s her anal circumference?

I’ll go with “superior” since, ya know, Applejack isn’t comically proportioned.