Me and my friends were joking about casting Mario characters for future movies and I came up with some of my own personal choices:
I think it wod be fitting if Daisy was played by Samantha Mathis from the live action movie, but for a more fitting choice I also suggested Kristen Wig on account of Pringus McDingus dubbing her voice with Daisy.
Susan Egan I would choose for Rosalina since I think her voice would be perfect for the character.
Many people suggested Danny DeVito as Wario which could not only work but would be fitting since Charlie Day has worked with him before, people have also suggested Pedro Pascal but I’m not sure that’s as appropriate a choice.
Waluigi I think should be played by Tom Kenny no questions about it.
I saw someone suggest Wallace Shawn as E. Gad which I think would sound great.
Kristen Schaal would be perfect to play Toadette.
James Franco should be Funky Kong just to connect with Seth Rogen.
And I didn’t have anyone specific in mind, but they certainly should bring in Jordan Peele to interact with Keegan-Michael Key; maybe another Toad or a Koopa who’s not working for Bowser or something.
There are some I didn’t include either cause I couldn’t think of anything like Bowser Jr. and the Koopalings, and I left out characters like Yoshi and Birdo just because I can only really see them using their in-game voices.