Viewing last 25 versions of comment by cloudkicker108 on image #1786402

"[@Minus":](/1786402#comment_7344390
[bq])  

> Being told to stop, even if she didn’t know why, still has no reasonable explanation for why it made her upset.[/bq]

 
What made her upset was what her friends told her. I know I would be pretty heartbroken if one of my closest friends told me point blank I would never improve at something I love not matter how much I try.

[bq]
 

> This wasn’t about thinking she’ll never improve.[/bq]

 
Except that's exactly what it was. _*Pinkie herself said so._

[bq]*
 

> But if you’re gonna tell someone else they’re wrong for not creating the same excuses, I have to butt in.[/bq]

 
First, I never said he was wrong. I was merely offering my perspective as as counterargument. That is how debates work, you know. Second, trying to understand a character's motivations is not the same as making excuses.

[bq]
 

> But it is objectively a terrible episode.[/bq]

 
And how come you are 100% right while I am 100% wrong? DoeIs the word "interpretation" not in your dictionary? Look, you dislike the episode all you want, but you have no right to claim it is objectively and factually terrible.

"@Minus":/1786402#comment_7344390
[bq]Being told to stop, even if she didn’t know why, still has no reasonable explanation for why it made her upset.[/bq]
What made her upset was what her friends told her. I know I would be pretty heartbroken if one of my closest friends told me point blank I would never improve at something I love not matter how much I try.

[bq]This wasn’t about thinking she’ll never improve.[/bq]
Except that's exactly what it was. _Pinkie herself said so._

[bq]But if you’re gonna tell someone else they’re wrong for not creating the same excuses, I have to butt in.[/bq]
First, I never said he was wrong. I was merely offering my perspective as as counterargument. That is how debates work, you know. Second, trying to understand a character's motivations is not the same as making excuses.

[bq]But it is objectively a terrible episode.[/bq]
And how come you are 100% right while I am 100% wrong? Does the word "interpretation" not in your dictionary? Look, you dislike the episode all you want, but you have no right to claim it is objectively and factually terrible.