I still have whatever I want you know that Sunset.

I choose Shimmer-chan, of course

@Step-chan  
[No joke, Come back tomorrow, 良い一日]

@BRONY_USA
 
LOL

[And your block will be lifted by tomorrow, Have a good day and for the Modéland]

@BRONY_USA
 
Had to look that up.

@Step-chan  
[You are now Block from the Modecan Government]

@BRONY_USA
 
???

@Step-chan  
(Silent & Cricket noise)

@BRONY_USA
 
In no particular order.
 
Pony category:  
Fluttershy  
Coco Pommel  
Somnambula  
Milk Drop  
Sunset Sorbet
 
Dragon Quest category:  
Female Merchant from Dragon Quest III  
Meena and Maya from Dragon Quest IV  
Debora from Dragon Quest V  
Ashlynn from Dragon Quest VI
 
Pokemon category:  
Gym Leader Erika  
Gym Leader Roxanne  
Gym Leader Candice  
Gym Leader Skyla  
Female Ace Trainer - Pokemon Sun & Moon  
Trial Captain Mallow
 
Other:  
Asha - Monster World IV  
Ukyo & Shampoo - Ranma 1/2
 
Wasn’t sure if you meant all or just pony related, so I posted them all.
 
That said, it’s closer to being something of a potential waifu catalog. :P
 
Although I do imagine some have a way bigger number of candidates or waifus that would put my list to shame.
 
Due to some characters being in another category, I left out Stellar Flare and Golden Brooch, my favorite canon and oc MILFs. Kind of weird that both of them are red-heads like my mom, considering that I prefer black hair a little bit more in real life.

@Step-chan  
Who are your candidates?

And I see you’ve claimed Twilight as yours, eh Sunset?

I don’t have a waifu, but I do have candidates for a waifu.

@Amagan  
Yes, I can.

@Amagan  
Quadramist?

@Zaknel  
No, no you cannot. This is a no trigonometry zone. Check your fancy math at the door.

I can have both.

@Zaknel  
[trig-gered]

Can I not be a trigamist?

“And the purple one is mine!” she added.

@Background Pony #4BFC  
You got that right.

@sTs  
Sexy waifu

my 3 Dakis that show a total of 4 girls say otherwise

Ok, Starlight it is then.  

Not with Chrysalis. She can turn in all of the Waifus!