Derpibooru
Filters (Default) SettingsRegisterLogin
Rainbow Rocks 10th Anniversary - Let's celebrate the 10th anniversary of Rainbow Rocks with an art event! Here
45 85 16 69 28
Subscribe
Galleries
Featured in
Sign in to create a gallery
Related
View VS Download DS
Uploaded by Background Pony #D66C
 900x1050 PNG 833 kB
Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Sky Railroad Merch Shop!

Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!

Description

I know what’s coming. No way am I revealing which user I am.

Tags
Edit History (14)
semi-grimdark
37195 anonymous artist
5265 edit
178396 edited screencap
94171 screencap
300487 big macintosh
34445 marble pie
8576 sugar belle
3863 earth pony
529667 pony
1662474 g4
2094672 the big mac question
1171 4chan
6995 abuse
9984 answer
184 background pony strikes again
1351 bad end
2886 despair
288 downvote bait
1200 engagement ring
239 female
1869961 gallows humor
23 gradient background
28991 grimcute
440 heartbreak
923 heartbroken marble
109 hoof hold
13800 implied hanging
110 implied marblemac
66 implied shipping
7548 implied straight
6771 implied suicide
258 intertwined trees
236 male
572771 marblebuse
19 marriage proposal
672 music notes
4922 noose
590 op is a duck
4928 question
1451 rope
16510 sad
32149 ship:sugarmac
1057 shipping
262078 side chick
81 smiling
420184 solo
1476479 straight
185541 suicidal
126 this will end in death
3848 this will end in tears
4448 this will end in tears and/or death
2883 tree
52464 wat
22115
Report Share List favoriters

Comments

Edit Preview
Syntax quick reference: **bold** *italic* ||hide text|| `code` __underline__ ~~strike~~ ^sup^ %sub%

Detailed syntax guide

28 comments posted
MrSBright
An Artist Who Rocks - 100+ images under their artist tag
Artist -

A Stallion with No Plan
@Wild Stallions
 
It was admitted it was just a potion. Being forced to love over having feelings for another character are not the same thing. Also, there are so many characters that they cannot give a day-to-day so it feels that justified. Think of it this way, we learn just like his younger sister learns. Most have been as supportive since.
Posted Report
Copper Knight

@Wild Stallions  
We’ve already been over this and the most evidence you have is her fangirling over his voice. Period. That still doesn’t change the fact that Hearts and Hooves established that they are not a couple and won’t be a couple with them even messing with the CMC at the end about it. To turn them into a couple, validates the CMC’s actions in the first place.
 
The episode also establishes that the two of them are friends and we see them hang out. At that point in all of the episodes, Big Mac was not shown to have many friends. Him and Spike didn’t start to hang out until season 5. But that’s all the two ultimately were - friends.
 
And there’s absolutely nothing wrong with that. The two stayed friends and did not move beyond that.
Posted Report
Wild Stallions
An Artist Who Rocks - 100+ images under their artist tag
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition
Artist -

@Copper Knight  
Spare me the denial.
 
@Wild Stallions  
@Beau Skunky
@Wild Stallions
What did you debunk though? You haven’t said anything to debunk my repeated statement that just, because you see two characters together, doesn’t mean they’re in a BF & GF relationship.
Let’s see, in this shot, not only are the two walking together but also Big Mac is even carrying a fruit basket. A gift from him to her or vice versa?
And how about this, a guy and girl together late at night at the amusement park. Gee, what could possibly be the purpose of their trip?
And look at these pictures on the wall of the CMC’s clubhouse. These all shots of characters that they’ve helped out in one way or another or as they put it “satisfied clients”. Gee, what could Big Mac and Cheerilee possibly be so satisfied about? Maybe it’s the one we were actually privy to: they becoming an item.
Nuff said.
Are you going to continue denying that there was ever a thing between Cheerilee and Big Mac?
Posted Report
Copper Knight

@Wild Stallions  
Your analysis is still only based on the concept that the two are in love by being in proximity of each other for subsequent episodes despite the message of that episode and the fact that they end it on them walking off together as friends.
Posted Report
Wild Stallions
An Artist Who Rocks - 100+ images under their artist tag
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition
Artist -

@Copper Knight  
@Wild Stallions
Swept under the rug…by having the episode flat out state that him and Cheerilee’s romantic feelings were just that of the love poison and showing that Marble, learned, broke, and then got over it by the end of the special?
 
Do you really need me to post the analysis of the post-love potion episodes again? Constantly doubling down on that half-baked excuse after being shown it cannot apply to subsequent episodes is trolling.
Posted Report
Copper Knight

@Wild Stallions  
Swept under the rug…by having the episode flat out state that him and Cheerilee’s romantic feelings were just that of the love poison and showing that Marble, learned, broke, and then got over it by the end of the special?
Posted Report
Wild Stallions
An Artist Who Rocks - 100+ images under their artist tag
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition
Artist -

@MrSBright  
Some fans are still really bothered by the cute and genuine love of a baker and a farmer.
 
Could it be because it came out of the blue and swept the farmer’s previously established relationships with the teacher and the rock farmer’s daughter under the rug?
Posted Report
Background Pony #89E2
Such a pity, she was a mare that really liked to hang around.
 
It seems that her life is hanging by a thread.
 
She is on the ropes. If only she would have gotten some help sooner she might knot have gotten like this. But alas, it might be too late for it to be of noose.
Posted Report
Background Pony #73EF
We still have the upcoming Season 10 comic books. Maybe Marble Pie will find her happy ending in Season 10.
Posted Report