I thought that men could have children together as long as they had a female willing and ab egg. Supposedly they’d use both of the males sperm. I can’t remember too well, read it awhile ago.

@Ruskraaz  
But the pony has the same eyes as Rarity also Surprise is more like a PinkieShy kid

“Mommies.”
 
God, that sounds so unorthodox to say.

This joke is amusing.

@Shepherd
 
If the Cakes can have a pegasus and an unicorn, Rarity and Fluttershy can have four earth ponies.
 
…but yeah, I’m leaning more towards Surprise than Rarity.

Fucking time travel, how does it work?

Headcanon accepted.

They would not be earth ponies.

Fluttershy’s hair must be really massive for people to not notice it’s the only thing the banner mares and her share in common.

I guess no one remembers Surprise’s colors…

kids@AndersK  
there was an anime called vandread where a planet of full women could have kids doing exactly da, but the guys of the man planet could also have children, they never explained how…just that “kids are made in a fabric”.

@Background Pony  
In order for a child to be female it has to be XX, in order to be male it has to be XY or YY.  
No one in their right mind would have two male parents go through this though. The reason being is the kid would die pretty darn fast. I could get a new driver’s license at the dmv faster than the kid would die if it had two genetic male parents.
 
Sorry guys soon women won’t need men anymore for reproduction, but men still need women.

I was actually troubled by the fact that those mares all looked the same… could they really be some sort of magical clone spawn of some sort?

@CannonFodder  
Of course the f-f child would have to be XX but wouldn’t a m-m child beable to be an XX, XY, or YY?  
I would think that would be the case.

I don’t know. I always felt they looked more like Fleur de Lis than Rarity.

@Rarity
 
@Rarity  
You both look the same, ok?

So Rarity and Fluttershy actually did it XD

@CannonFodder  
No one would get YY. Obviously a same sex pregnancy would require artificial insemination, and as such a doctor would be able to prevent that kind of mix up.  
For two males to have a child made this way they would need a nucleous-less oocyte (Egg) and a willing woomb to implant it into, but it could be done. The woman would likely need to be immunosuppressed to avoid rejection though, as the child in her womb would have no genetics in common with her.

@Rarity  
It must be one of us.

Only a fourth of magical gay spawn among males would die because of double-Y. The rest because of the lack of midichlorians

CannonFodder speaks the truth, I remember reading about scientists successfully creating offspring off of two female mice a few years back. I wonder how far they’ve come along since then?

@CannonFodder  
Science truly is a wonderful thing.

@CannonFodder
 
Oh…my…God…

@CannonFodder  
See! They don’t need males anymore!  
We need to save our penises!

On the topic of “magical lesbian spawn” you can actually create offspring by combining the dna of two females in the lab now. The problem is that you can’t do it with same-sex male couple cause that would lead to children with YY chromosomes, which would lead to the child in all probability dying of something. Having two female parents on the other hand all it does is produce female offspring.