Thats your opininon :)

i listened to mike the microphone read it and loved it … i couldn’t actually read the wall of text.

u Wot M8!?

Personally, I thought it was boring. So boring I gave up after just one screenful of text.

Meh.

I liked it, but didn’t love it. The premise is nice, every child’s dream made reality far too late in life and being an adult with the situation. Because it really is, every kid wanted to go on adventures with their favorite character, and then having the scenario play out as an adult, where the innocent youthfulness dried up ages ago, and having to bear responsibilities.
 
@KirbyfanNeox- I don’t know, I didn’t like it, but it was fitting to the story, that all endings aren’t happy, but there can be a silver lining (being that scrapbook and the letter). Makes it a bit more realistic, ironically given the situation.
 
What kills me is the time the story takes place, over several years, a decade or so, which makes it suck more that everything he did went away, but then again, it’s like watching your child grow up and move out. It also, given the start of the story, made him a better person. You could of replaced RD with an orphan, and reached the same conclusion.

The only thing I found shitty was the ending. Specifically, erasing Rainbow Dash’s “Dashie” memories and removing any trace of her having existed in our world (save for a scrapbook, IIRC).

Iknow it’s against the rules, but I want to tag this as LIES!

I tried to read it… but the beginning was too drab. Fanfiction really isn’t my thing. The only one I liked was Silent Ponyville. Though I loved the series.

For some reason I liked the severing.  
Don’t know why exactly tho.

Not too into fanfiction. Just never appealed to me.

@64 Gramatically correct and no ungodly ridiculous OCs. I saw neither in that fic. After that, it’s mostly based on opinion.

The only Pony one I liked was Unintentionally Yours.  
I sorta like that one Snips / DT fic, if for no other reason than for Snips (SNIPS) being in a serious place in the story.  
Most are okay, I guess.

Yeah is there a consensus on what fics are good?

You just hating on its swag.