>because we could go see what the good version of this comic was like
 
And that’s where they got me. As usual, terrible though it may be, /mlp/ delivers.

It doesn’t matter if Reflections was good or not. Statler and Waldorf will heckle it anyway. Because they are goddamn pros.

@dynamicv  
I didn’t have much trouble keeping up with it, but oh well. I guess they can’t all be amazing.

That is classic Statler and Waldorf XD

@FancyCat2008  
I think I know the real reason a lot people don’t like it: It’s confusing.
 
The most important half of the story is the history of Starswirl and Celestia, and it is told through a bunch of flashbacks and conversations between the Princesses. All of which are out of order. Piecing together the big picture is hard, and there are several critical details that completely change the perception of Celestia’s character if missed or put in the wrong spot on the timeline.

@FancyCat2008  
There have been countless threads about this, you should go find one.

Am I the only guy that liked Reflections? What don’t other people like about it? Is it just the Celestia romance? I thought it was kinda cute.

Poor Cook…

Ah, those guys.
 
Always a laugh.