@gg666  
these guys had no prior expirence, it’s pretty decent considering that
 
Did they really? I’m not questioning what you said, I’m just surprised. I’m planning an ambitious animated project, and I’m doing loads and loads of training/testing for it. You’d expect anybody to do the same…

I understood them perfectly.  
Also, Breeze Rider is best pony. Second best is Mr. Strong due to the fact that his VA sound like he’s at the brink of laughter.

Half the characters had such thick accents they were nearly unintelligible.

Yeah, the Pony Creator designs destroyed the whole thing.

I swear at one point I thought I was watching The Room.

The biggest problem with the fanimation wasn’t the ocs, they’re some of the better oc pallettes I’ve seen.
 
That problem, in my opinion, is them using the pony creator base shapes, that perfect profile perspective just sucks.

….sigh Im just worried that this will scare them off from animating and getting better for good…..
 
the top rated comment on youtube calls them cancer

^Double Rainboom?
 
Judging by the previews it’s gonna be sweet.

That was just… okay.
 
Okay animation, okay story, okay voice acting.
 
I’m just looking forward to that OTHER fan episode.

Yeah, I would like to see them try to do better.

okay, youtubers are the most brain dead people on the planet

Ok, for some reason, from what I’ve gathered, the story line reminds me a tiny bit of Super Paper Mario…. like every other show I watch or song I listen too. The guy looks into a secret book and then becomes evil, then they try to kill everyone. The good guys stop him and he snaps out of it.

these guys had no prior expirence, it’s pretty decent considering that

Even EqD thinks it’s pretty meh.

alot of ass holes in the comment section of that video.

Ew.

I liked it and the whole OC thing is not a problem for me.

 
Overall it was pretty nice. Many problems, but it also was impressive.

That sure was an animation.
 
Also, the blue Pegasus sounds like a cross between Christopher Walken and PsychedelicEyeball.

All of the work put into this…Instead of using OC’s they could’ve actually made something good.  

“Hey, it wasn’t the best, but it’s certainly not the worst! I never ever could do something like this. I actually liked the accents. But the voice acting needs way work, like with the emphasis and clarity, and most important, EMOTION, so it was meh. It needs WAY better lip synching, though, so try to get someone who can do that. I understand that the ponies were made with the pony creator, but I really think you need to get an actual animator, all the movements look stiff and wrong, and the flying is really crappy. I actually did like the story, even if it was pretty rushed, and like others, I didn’t understand what was happening half the time. If we get more explanation in the next episode, I’ll be happier. Catchy music was catchy. I liked it. The characters’ designs were nice and I could certainly see them in the actual show. But like I said, they look pretty bad in some shots because of the limited perspective. Just get someone who’s animated MLP fan clips before and it should be a little better. I liked it. :D And Breezie was adorable. The thing I have the most problem with is flippin Pony Creator animation. NONONO. It makes it look really, really crappy. You guys did a pretty good job with it, though. I cringe at all pony creator animations, though, so it might just be me. I’d rather have worse animation without pony creator that a little bit better animation with it. It really limits what you can do. But I’m looking forward to more. Just listen to us and you will be fine. Get many more people on board with this so we can get way better quality out soon! Good luck :D”