@Background Pony #584E  
Maybe Rarity’s tail would taste like plums? It’s the only purple fruit I could think of.

Pinkie’s tail probably tastes like cotton candy
 
Rainbow’s tail either tastes like skittles or REALLY spicy. (probably the former if Applejack bites it so much, and if Fluttershy can bite it without her mane and tail starting on fire)
 
Twilight’s tail probably tastes like grapes
 
Applejack’s tail would probably taste like hay, since we’re talking about ponies and consistent with this pic
 
Fluttershy’s tail, well, someone else said bubblegum so we could go with that
 
Rarity’s tail… what would Rarity’s tail taste like? I already used grapes for Twilight, which is often associated with dark purple. What flavor would you associate with the shade of purple that Rarity’s tail is? (If all else fails I can say marshmallows)

@Jarkes  
Yummy.

@EmployeeAMillion
 
Bubble gum.

What do you think Fluttershy’s tail tastes like?