Well, it was said that Fluttershy was just designed like that to look like Bambi. And it’s also possible that Fluttershy just had an early growth spirt. If this size was because of her being “a teenager” I think she’d be more than just one year older.

@Background Pony #AE79  
haha i said okay like i dont care im so edgy xd

Fluttershy is the oldest. Nuff said.

@thps48  
Because arguing is fun.

I don’t know what you people are arguing over. Why not just simply say you don’t believe in this theory, add a period, and hit post? <_<

okay

@Background Pony #2562  

 
See, now you can make that claim, but unless it’s confirmed in the show, (Which it isn’t.) it’s just your headcanon.
 

 
No one here is mad but you, bruv.
 

 
Okay, first of all: Prove it. I mean, yeah, it’s probably true to some extent at least, but unless they confirm it in canon, you can’t make claims like that as if they were fact.
 
Secondly: Even if that were true, they still go through puberty, and puberty still effects each individual differently.
 

 
You see how my comment wasn’t replying directly to you?
 
Yeah, that’s because that sentence wasn’t aimed at you specifically.
 
Stop taking it so personally.

@Background Pony #2562  
Also Narlepoax III never mentioned humans or Equestria Girls

@Background Pony #2562  
Pre-Teens can apply to there appearance here to you know

@Narlepoax III  
It isn’t hard to understand but unlike you I see actual evidence of it cause in a lot of episode including season 8 and that applejack episode big mac and her were both teens and not short fillies like they were before when they were fillies and that’s the teen body for an mlp characters which fluttershy already took when they were fillies themselves. calm your nuts. Everyone on Derpibooru over reacts like usual over a cartoon anyways that’s why otherwise the wouldn’t have made her the ONLY one to be that way. I could care less about your personal life and when you were in 4th grade they are cartoon ponies they age differently than you and i. Humans do not apply to this. Why is common decency so hard to understand for you? Instead of putting Why is it so hard to understand that children can grow at different rates?  
for fuck sakes. Seriously what did anybody do to you? Get a pencil shoved up your ass? I stated one thing and what I get back is a comment trying to belittle me or some shit. anyways have fun I only came on here for one comment.

Why is it so hard to understand that children can grow at different rates?
 
Fuck’s sake, when I was in fourth grade, there was a boy who was 6’2” and a girl with D-cup breasts. There was also a boy so reedy he could hide behind a pencil and a girl who was 3’4”. Kids at that age (the age Flutters is in the picture) can run the gambit from almost fully-grown to barely bigger than toddlers. Why can’t she just be a tall kid for her age?

Yes, Fluttershy is most likely the oldest of them I could see it. Being we already see what ponies look like as teens the same form, shape and height so thatd mean since the rest were fillies when she was a teen most likely a young teen pinkie pie was a year so shed be the second oldest so if shes a teen she be around 13 in human years and pinkie pie probably 12 that and season 8 school daze we know teenagers go there to learn in highschool level i think and as we see in one of them they were the same height as them and form back then and applejack grew to that size after being a filly and fluttershy was already that size when they WERE fillies because we have the special cutiemark bond they all had to get it at the same time due to rainbow dashes sonic rainboom. so fluttershy would probably be the oldest because we know horses/ponies can grow fast very fast so if shes in that teen form while they were fillies she is probably the oldest just looking at it should tell enough in itself

@Prof.NightJack  
It was poor wording on their part? I see.
 
What is the meaning of “grasping at straws”?

@thps48  
It was just about how the “desperate” part was not true in this case.  
If the proponents of the theory want to talk of it then they can’t be grasping at straws and then call the people that do no believe it and have reason to think it’s not true as being desperate to disprove it.

@Background Pony #92CE  
In life, mares refer to adult females, making fillies “underage”. For horses, adulthood is age four, but the Metallica episode seems to suggest pony ages are different from the real life animals they’re designed after, with five-year-old Sweetie Belle being the size of Pipsqueak, suggesting pony sizes shift from Pipsqueak to Apple Bloom to filly Flutter to cookie cutter mare in the intermittent years.
 
@Prof.NightJack  
I’m assuming there’s an actual point to telling proponents of the theory they’re wasting your time by discussing said theory you’re greatly disinterested in.

Actually fluttershy was a filly at that flight camp cuz she said “filly” to the cmcs and it would be weird for a filly to be bullying a teenager and that pic of Applejack she wasnt that much older than applebloom

@Background Pony #1670  
Tall filly? Late bloomer? Super awkward youngster?

that would mean that fluttershy didn’t get her cutiemark until she was a teenager.

@Ping_chan  
And pony Jesus died for our sins.

@Narlepoax III  
Ooohhh, if Pinkie Pie were born in 1983,then she could be just about as old as I am! I like this head canon.

@Ping_chan  
2016, 2011, 2005, 1994, 1988, 1983, & 1977 are the most recent.
 
But that hypothesis is based on the presumption that Equestria tracks years with our decidedly Cristian B.C./A.D. method. Which seems… Unlikely, at best.
 
I mean, it’s a hard enough pill to swallow the notion that they have our Gregorian calendar.

@Background Pony #F263  
Okay I was curious and Google’d this, there is a Tuesday, May 3, 2011.  
So then Google gives me 5 years 10 months 25 days…  
5 years old is pretty grown up for a pone I guess?  
Unless someone can find another occurrence before 2011 when May 3rd landed on a Tuesday?

yep shes defiantly the oldest we saw applejack as a teen with the same size of fluttershy so we know applejack was no fillie a young teen and fluttershy was already that size when they were fillies physical proof now we finally know lol https://mlpforums.com/uploads/post_images/img-2754754-1-maxresdefault.jpg