Uploaded by blizzard64 
4640x4464 PNG 6.77 MB
Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!
Description
Hi guys, first of all I will make it clear that this is like a theory or rather a scenario “What if ..?”
In this example will be: Star Swirl the bearded.
We’ve heard of him since the first season and I always felt intrigued when they talked about him. And now he’s a canon in season 7. The truth, the character disappointed me a little for his behavior, but that’s my thing …
Now I will talk about the timelines in which Star Swirl appears (The number of timelines, I list them by a random number or by the number of the season).
The Timeline 7: In this timeline is the one we already know, it is season 7 and we see a Star Swirl blinded by his pride and he does not listen to others, and he is grumpy and learns from his mistakes until the end.
Timeline 4: This is season 4, when you talk about Tirek, it shows a Flashback where his brother Scorpan makes friends with a unicorn, obviously it’s Star Swirl … but I thought that Star Swirl did not know anything about friendship? What happened to this friendship? … What would have happened, maybe Scorpan leave a scar on Star Swirl and that’s why he thinks: “A villain, always a villain” (Maybe it’s not a timeline, maybe it’s the reason why Star Swirl did not to have friends).
Timeline 5: We also know this, there was an explanation in EG Rainbow Rock, and in the comic: Fiendship is magic # 3 reveals how Star Swirl defeats the sirens alone. Of course you will say it was before season 7, but remember that if the sirens are already a canon, then “the alternate universes (like Equestria Girls could already be canon)”, then the parallel universes or time lines could exist.
Timeline 10: In fact my favorite timeline, shows us a more fatherly, sympathetic, empathic Star Swirl, etc. Besides that he loved studying dimensional travel. And he was the one who created the prototype of a magic mirror to travel to other dimensions (and then create the mirror to go to the human world).
Okay, you think that one of these Star Swirl, is able to travel to another universe to know himself. (Like Rick Sanchez of “Rick and Morty”)
Which of these 3 Star Swirl is your favorite?
In this example will be: Star Swirl the bearded.
We’ve heard of him since the first season and I always felt intrigued when they talked about him. And now he’s a canon in season 7. The truth, the character disappointed me a little for his behavior, but that’s my thing …
Now I will talk about the timelines in which Star Swirl appears (The number of timelines, I list them by a random number or by the number of the season).
The Timeline 7: In this timeline is the one we already know, it is season 7 and we see a Star Swirl blinded by his pride and he does not listen to others, and he is grumpy and learns from his mistakes until the end.
Timeline 4: This is season 4, when you talk about Tirek, it shows a Flashback where his brother Scorpan makes friends with a unicorn, obviously it’s Star Swirl … but I thought that Star Swirl did not know anything about friendship? What happened to this friendship? … What would have happened, maybe Scorpan leave a scar on Star Swirl and that’s why he thinks: “A villain, always a villain” (Maybe it’s not a timeline, maybe it’s the reason why Star Swirl did not to have friends).
Timeline 5: We also know this, there was an explanation in EG Rainbow Rock, and in the comic: Fiendship is magic # 3 reveals how Star Swirl defeats the sirens alone. Of course you will say it was before season 7, but remember that if the sirens are already a canon, then “the alternate universes (like Equestria Girls could already be canon)”, then the parallel universes or time lines could exist.
Timeline 10: In fact my favorite timeline, shows us a more fatherly, sympathetic, empathic Star Swirl, etc. Besides that he loved studying dimensional travel. And he was the one who created the prototype of a magic mirror to travel to other dimensions (and then create the mirror to go to the human world).
Okay, you think that one of these Star Swirl, is able to travel to another universe to know himself. (Like Rick Sanchez of “Rick and Morty”)
Which of these 3 Star Swirl is your favorite?
Source
not provided yet
Dramatic tone
yes
WOW, interesting… I like it :)
I imagine that Time line 5 is just a in-universe fictionalization of the facts. It is a story from 1000 years ago, so it is likely that it has changed from author to author, in the same way as the story of the Mare in the Moon. Or it could be that Star Swirl was a dick and told everyone that he defeated the sirens by himself. I would not be surprised, considering that Applejack told her sister that she defeated the Storm King.
To simplify, I consider it more likely that the Star Swirl from other universe took the place of the original (from the time line 7) when he disappeared along with the Pillars. This “Star Swirl II: Electric Boogaloo” was responsible for the events of time line 4 and 10, and is perhaps native to the mirror universe or the EG universe.
Edited