reminds me of billy ray cyrus’ “it could have been me”

@J-90  
No, because Big Mac has enough love for all the mares. He has a big powerful…heart. Yeah, that’s it.

@Copper Knight  
AB was too busy crushing on Maud to notice.
 
@Background Pony #DC73  
i believe Pinkie considers herself to be in a relationship with the rest of Mane Six.

AD: Don’t be sad, Marble. You deserve a good stallion, a kind and loving gentlecolt who’ll take care of you always. But most importantly you need somepony who is, without a doubt, a genuine full-blooded relative.
 
AD: Oh, if only you had a brother, that would have been absolutely prefect. Hmm? Well, I guess there’s Limestone, she’s kind of like a stallion. Tough, rude, a good worker and aggressive. Or maybe it’s just that whole ‘tsun’ thing everypony’s always going on about.

@DashingJack  
Not exactly.  

It’s for the best. He might have been your cousin.

Suckerpunch right in the heart. The feels. THE FEELS!

Look on the bright side. At least, she can keep Limestone company in the Dateless Pie Sister Club. Well, I guess Pinkie’s in the club also, but she doesn’t seem the type to be at all bothered by it.

@FloydPinkerton  
Yep, because *urp- multiverse.

All Big Macintosh ships are valid. Simultaneously.

Yea, yeah you were.

Ouchies.  
My feelz.  
XO

I´m afraid you missed your chance.

You snooze you lose, bitch!

She got rocked.

That’s pretty much accurate.

Poor Marble.

@DonMaguz  
I love how you’re first assumption is pandering, and you are unable to fathom the possibility that your interpretation of their initial interactions was incorrect.

No, you didn’t wait. You suddenly developed feelings after 2 years (in universe) to pander onto some fancanons.

Right in the feels.

@Copper Knight  
A singular CMC and a pony who at that point was only ever a matchmaker for a couple who already had history together would not have made either of them go for it.

@Background Pony #683A  
AB was at the first meeting and Pinkie was trying to. It just wasn’t meant to be.

God dangit, the girl’s painfully shy- moreso than Big Mac! It would’ve been just as hard for her to make the first move on him as it would’ve been for Mac to get with Sugar Belle if he hadn’t had the CMC helping him out. I guarantee they would’ve jumped on the MarbleMac express first if they’d been around for their first meeting.

Yeah, I mean he didn’t get with Sugar Belle until a little over a year after meeting you.