I would defend her, even if it cost me my life! Bonus: would show her my house after school.

Find out who’s been harassing/bullying her, tell them to back off and then tell Fluttershy that I’ve figured out she’s had a crush on me and make her as my girlfriend. Which is, ironically, how that was with me in my school days except that I didn’t even learn about that until much later in life; honestly made me feel bummed out.

I honestly don’t see how anyone can bully such a pure soul like fluttershy  
What I would most likely do is ask her out on a date before anyone else

i’d let her know the feeling’s mutual c:

The least I could probably do is give her a hug.

@Lightning spyder  
Actually, I couldn’t do that. This comment, in my case, actually meant what I’d do if I could possibly go back to my teen years. Since we know that that can’t happen I’d have to ask her if she has a crush and if so, who it is. I’d then ask that person if he has a crush on anyone and if it’s Fluttershy, I’d try to get them together. It’ll take much convincing, I know, but it’ll be worth it. And of course I’d give those bullies tell them that if they were so attracted to her, why they didn’t use that time to actually be nice to her rather than treat her like crap. If they realize that they really could have, I’d tell them there’s big price to pay for the way they treated her which is losing their chance to hook up with her, cuz she’s already taken, and also I’ll be keeping an eye on them.

I’d just walk up to Fluttershy and bring to the side and then tell her to wait for me around the corner and tell her she can watch if she wants to, but refrain from making any noise. Then, I’d go up to the bullies and tell them if you want to be around her so badly then why don’t you take her out on a date? If they decide to take my advise, I’d tell them they are too late she’s already taken. If they ask me who the lucky guy is I’ll tell her it’s me.

I’d most likely freak out

I would ask her to be my gf

I Tell all the bronies that equestria girls fluttershy is real and show fluttershy some episodes of mlp as well as the equestria girls movies.

@Ebalosus  
Welcome to the Friendzone.  
Some deny it, some decry it.  
But we know better, don’t we?

I would search the bullies and smash them!!! D:< after I would search Fluttershy and surprise her with a kiss

PLAN 1.hug 2. Punch haters 3.repeat

@Background Pony #DCFA  
Actually, just leave entirely.

@Background Pony #DCFA  
Sounds like you’re trying out for an episode of Criminal Minds.

@Background Pony #DCFA  
There isn’t a microgram of humor in this comment. Sick troll.

I’m gonna take it from the friend-zone to the end-zone! Thanks, Iron Will!

@raw19
 
Heh, that last one XD

@Background Pony #44DB
 
OR a non-lesbian girl OR a gay guy OR Monkey D. Luffy.

@raw19
 
AND THEN WONDER WHY SIMILAR SITUATIONS HAVE NEVER HAPPENED TO ME IN REAL LIFE!!!

Bring up the rumors the next time we’re alone and ask if they’re true. Then ask if she’ll go out with me.

disregard rumors because its obviously a prankish set up for embarassment