@Background Pony #522E  
Don’t even.

It’s clearly Berry Punch with extra bandages around the mouth.

I still think it’s Berry Punch.

I like Fluttershy’s mane here. Very pretty.

@Somber Star  
That’s not how bandages work you obtuse curtain rod.

 
The existence of this .gif is one thing I like about this conversation.

@Somber Star  
….it’s obviously not berry punch.. i feel like your just making bullshit up just to argue.
 
please stop with this dumb useless argument..

@Somber Star  
The only one getting emotional here is you, bro.

@Somber Star  

What? I don’t see any signs of damage on the tail.

@zippysqrl  
You’re getting awfully emotional about this, and your insistence is not making you any more right. Like I said, the disparity with her apparent facial structure can be explained by the bandages, and be honest, that’s the only significant difference. Eye shines are not consistent. Hell, as this picture shows, features as major as wings are not even consistent. Your only supporting evidence is the apparent shape of her snout.

@Somber Star  
1: They ARE clearly visible.  
2: Not every appearing pony has a name/identity.  
@Somber Star  
3: I don’t need to, mares and stallions have similar body types and can vary in size  
4: He also doesn’t have any shines in his eyes, another difference between mares and stallions in the show  
5: Your ONLY supporting evidence for your argument is that it’s he has the same body colours. Fun fact: Body colours are reused all the damn time, just look at fluttershy’s hair and pinkie’s body, or the yellow balloon on pinkie’s cutie mark and fluttershy’s body, _{(or on another image, Applejacks hair and Fluttershy’s body)}. Your other excuse is that Berry got so horribly maimed that she somehow managed to change every feature about her body that makes her a mare.  
6:  
 
Now stop.

Also, you still haven’t explained the mare size and body type.

@zippysqrl  
All the features you stated are not clearly visible, or have rational explanations given the extent of injuries implied. And if it’s not Berry Punch, then who is it?

@Somber Star  
All those features I stated are features of stallions in the show. It’s not Berry Punch, stop trying to convince yourself otherwise.

@zippysqrl  
She is covered in bandages, her tail is obviously damaged, and she’s missing a lot of hair in general. Why would eyelashes be excluded?

@Somber Star  
Shorter tail, stallion shaped head (muzzle is most obvious), no eyelashes.

@zippysqrl  
What makes you say that? She’s the same size and build as the other mares, and has Berry Punch’s colors.

@zippysqrl
 
When I looked at the small thumbnail I was thinking for a half second “huh what Berry Punch I don’t remember that”
 
That would have been some drunken accident.

@Somber Star  
Well, for starters that’s a stallion, not a mare, so it’s not berry punch.

Poor Berry Punch. Had the roughest day a pony could survive, can’t even get tagged in her own hospital picture.

Also Pinkie is being bipedal for some reason.

@JP  
Fluttershy’s wings are missing.

@JP  

 
Wingless Fluttershy.

@JP  
Look at Fluttershy’s wings.