I don’t want to be too harsh on Ol’ Cult Leader Starlight, but I have to think that she wouldn’t get along very well with Reformed Starlight. Cult Leader Starlight couldn’t stand the idea of ponies having their own identity. It’s ironic because it turns out that she happens to be among Equestria’s elite when it comes to magical ability. It makes you wonder what lengths she must have gone to to deny that part of herself for so long.
Well, you give me something to think about. Actually I believe that they still would get along, but for a different reason. Actuallly Actually I think that these two shouldn’t be two different personalities. It’s more two sides of one coin, I you know what I mean. You usually don’t change 180° just because you recognize you’re wrong. And I’m verrrrrry pleased, that the show staff acknowledged this with Marks for Efforts. I can’t say how much this episode means to me considering Starlights character development. ;-)
Here is my reason, why I like Equality Starlight:
- Being proud in your beliefs
- No pony will be left behind
- Always filled with cheer
- Knowing that all your friends will be there too
- Don’t have to wait to find out your destiny
- Don’t be separate (as a German who actually has experienced the reunification of Germany, you may can imagne, what this means to me)
- No Ego-filled competition (everypony wins!)
- Everyone is equal, no one is superior
- Working as a team
- See eye-to-eye with others
- Learn to act as one
- Learn to simplify
Seriously, most people like the reformed Changelings for acting as a swarm, but Equality is bad!? Ugh!
Starlight has build up an entire community around these standards. And I’m very happy, that the people of Our Town still live and work together. Yes, the “I steal your Cutie Mark (evil laughter here)” plot was understandable. And I’m fine with everyone get them back, Starlight has learnt her lesson, yada, yada, yada… But I still believe, that the Equality community was not bad at all. It based on a misapprehension, because Starlight thought Sunburst has quit the friendship with her because he received his cutie mark. Actually it was because he was unable to complete Celestias School of Magic (what makes me wonder about the high standards there, but Unicorn society is a touchy topic at all).
So, what’s my point? I think, that Equality could have worked, if the Mane 6 didn’t burst in for plot convenience. My headcanon: the Tree of Harmony knows what it is doing. Starlight was and is needed elsewhere, for Equestria’s sake. That’s cool, I love it. But don’t mess with my Equality Appreciation. Equality was not wrong. ;-D
So, thanks to all in this thread for vent my feelings about this. MegaAnimationFan, I’m sorry for being offensive and lash out to you. I should have know better. I’m good with all of us back on track in our common admiration for Starlight Glimmer. Maybe we have different reasons to like her, but she is “best” pony for all of us. ;-D
(I put best in quotation marks, because I personally don’t belief in best pony) (_)!