On this list  

I think Ocellus should be on here.

@Background Pony #0086  
Lightning Dust, Vapor Trail, and Shimmy Shake
 
They are tagged…

Nice seeing Coco Pommel, Somnambula and Shimmy Shake on this.

Cool list.

That Luna model was not even in season 1.
 
Also:  

@Alexander Cupo  
They’re the same thing.

@DrakeyC  
True true, but do I use white or do I use RGB: #FFFFFF

Pretty good picks, aside from Luna (meme-tier waifu; also not the S1 version).

@Alexander Cupo  
Copy this one, it’s a blank white background and the text is all far enough from the images to cut them out safely.

I would love for a blank version of this.

I only disagree with 9. I don’t have the slightest idea who this character is. I’d have thrown Trixie in there. I forget if 8 or 9 are where she had her best episodes.

Yes.  
Not horrible by any means, but no, the correct answer is Cloudchaser.  
Given that she’s the only new female character of any real significance the whole (short) season, I grudgingly have to agree.  
Maybe if you’re a baby dragon imprinted on female unicorns, but no, that should be Rainbow Dash.  
Hell yes.  
Yes, but only because Minuette’s not technically a new character.  
Not a terrible answer, nor would Gabby be, but the correct answer is Molly.  
No, Sonata Dusk.  
Yes, though Pear Butter would also be a good answer except…  
 
Oh Celestia, yes.  
Yes, Shimmy Shake or Lighthoof, coin toss.  
Yeah, I’d have to agree. Not a wide pool to pick from, but she was quite endearing.

Mine are  
1.Rarity  
2.Princess Luna  
3.Sunset Shimmer  
4.Shimmy Shake and LightHoof  
5.Autumn Blaze

Definitely agree with rarity though it is tough with kerfuffle as I like tempest as well.

How about night glider

@CalypsoFantasy  
I’d hate to be a jerk like him but I’d love to date Maud.

I agree on 8, 9 and the specials. For 7 Sphinx edges out Somnambula a bit. For season 1…well, that’s when my beloved Redheart first appeared.

Winner - Sunset Shimmer

What about fire flare

I had a few hard choices to make. In the end it comes down to personal tastes and preferences. Feel free to make your own list, since it will mostly likely mean more cute ponies for everyone to see.

Sugar belle and luster dawn

I know, but her later design is so much better. I go by season of first appearance according to the rules I (arbitrarily) made up.

The only ones I definitely agree with are Coco Pommel, Vapor Trail, and Sunset Shimmer. Shimmy Shake is pretty good but I prefer Lighthoof.