@Pepsi_Al
It’s been awhile. Any new thoughts on the subject now that the show’s been concluded?

@moonchosen  
Well it didn’t deconfirm about the sisters being born alicorns.  
Just that no natural alicorns were born after Equestria was founded(till Flurry Heart happened).

@moonchosen: Not really.

@Pepsi_Al  
The premier of Season 6 must have REALLY gotten under your skin then.

@Tragiclady: Same mind, different body. Literally.

Would Nightmare Rarity x Nightmare Moon be selfcest? The tags seem to think so :D

@Background Pony #B647  
…The picture would suggest otherwise.

@The CLaUD: I doubt NMR would even be calling herself that. Even literally.

@Background Pony #DADC: I can attest to that. Since, some time ago, I had a debate with someone who somehow didn’t think that the thing that possessed Rarity and turned her into NMR, and what turned Luna into NMM, were one and the same. Instead, he somehow thought NMR was the result of Rarity possessed by Shadowfright. How that works is beyond me.
 
And heck! I even have a co-worker who seems to have put no reading comprehension into the chapter books. Specifically, The Journal of the Two Sisters. Seeing as he thought Luna and Celestia were born as Unicorns as opposed to Alicorns. I even showed him paragraphs proving otherwise, but he still persisted. Likely meaning that he was just trying to get under my skin.

@Background Pony #DADC
 
Sadly this is true.

@Background Pony #18C5
 
Some people just put no effort into reading comprehension when it comes to IDW, because they need to create plot holes that aren’t there.

@Tragiclady  

 
It should count as selfcest though. It’s made quite clear in the NMR arc that Nightmare Rarity is Nightmare Moon in a new form, and it’s even more solidified that Nightmare Moon is Nightmare Rarity in her “Fiendship is Magic” issue.
 
I realize this comment is late as hell…but it baffles me how this continues to fly over the head of the fandom even after two years.

Pat: She wants yous sweet GEM GEMS!

I love their adorable expressions.

“Girl Crush”
 
I got a girl crush, hate to admit it but  
I got a heart rush, ain’t slowin’ down  
I got it real bad, want everything she has  
That smile and the midnight laugh she’s givin’ you now
 
^{I know the song isn’t about this, but it’s the first thing I thought of.}

@atalarikt  
… this is one of the least plausible ones, for sake of not knowing that Nightmare can, uh, Nightmarify more than one pony at a time.  
Most f/f pony shippings don’t really have… any particular problems? Princess ships, age difference ships, incest ships, and enemyships are admittedly plausibility-reducers, but even all of those constitute a minority of possibilities or popular ones.

Nightmare Moon x Nightmare Rarity wouldn’t count as selfcest would it? I’ll admit I never read the Nightmare Rarity comics to see how much it changed dress horse’s personality.

@Background Pony #F9E5  
any ship with chrysalis is clearly the superior option

@soundtea  
This is good, but I somewhat prefer the idea of shipping Luna and Night Mare Moon. xD

don’t make be pick from NMM x NMR VS NMM x Chrysalis
 
;_;

I usually don’t like lesbian shippings, but this… is purely plausible, compared to 99.5% of any other lesbian shippings I’ve ever seen.

.

many yes

Surprised it took this long for the ship to happen.