@Scrounge  
Well he still clearly understands it was wrong because he’s reformed. That’s the whole point of a reformed villain. He wouldn’t do that again. I’m guessing that in this comic, Trixie would take Pinkie’s mouth off again if she still had the amulet. As for the other examples, yeah, Discord did shitty things in those two episodes, but they weren’t comparable to literally removing a part of someone’s body.
 
Also, I realize Pinkie might not hold a grudge, but just because the victim’s family forgives the murderer, that doesn’t mean the murderer doesn’t go to jail.

@secretivelyanonymous  
So… My opinion isn’t valid, what Pinkie’s opinion would probably be doesn’t matter… You’re being very dismissive.
 
As for Discoed: Everything he did in “Return of Harmony” (he ever reminisces fondly about some of it in “Dungeons and Discords”), which is worse than Trixie all on its own. Past that, there’s the things he did to screw with Twilight in “Three’s a Crowd” and “What about Discord”, and even on those occasions when he does apologize, it can be a bit questionable how sorry he actually is (he may have clearly regretted his betrayal in “Twilight’s Kingdom”, but he seems less regretful in most of his single-part episodes.

@Scrounge  

@secretivelyanonymous  
Yes, but the question wasn’t “if I was Pinkie”. And with that it crosses my mind that Pinkie doesn’t usually hold grudges.
 
And I am not referring to just one of Discord’s deeds. There’s plenty he’s done wrong, and only a small handful of those deeds for which he’s shown any remorse.

@Scrounge  
Well, Pinkie didn’t have what happened to her coming. Just because she was angry that Trixie insulted her family.
 
Also, which deed of Discord’s are you referring to?

@secretivelyanonymous  
Depends on the circumstances. If they beat me up for throwing their cat into the sewer, I’d have to admit I had it coming.
 
 
@secretivelyanonymous  

 
Not all of them. Discord wasn’t.

@WinterCutieMark  
Because they were sorry for it! Trixie isn’t sorry in this comic for what she did to Pinkie!

@secretivelyanonymous  
To be fair, characters on the show have been forgiven for worse things. Like, destroying all of equestria for example.

@OneOverTwo  
You… you just made my day.

@Scrounge  
It might be horrible but it’s TRUE.
 
If someone beat you up, stole your car, and burned your house down, and they later said, “I’m sorry I stole your car and burned your house down, but not sorry I beat you up,” would you feel they deserved forgiveness?

@Scrounge  
What? That sounds like an amazing name for a comic.

@secretivelyanonymous  
She can still theoretically be sorry for everything else she did.
 
More importantly, “Trixie Basically Gets Blackmailed Into Trying To Do Nice Things” is a horrible title for a comic.

@Scrounge
 
If she’s not sorry for what she did then she’s not redeemable. Period.

@secretivelyanonymous  
You think nopony else has ever wanted to do that? :P

“Redeemable Trixie”
 
>doesn’t think it’s wrong that she took Pinkie’s mouth
 
Seems legit.

Trixie’s therapist has obviously never met Pinkie Pie.

@Background Human  
“Best arson party EVER! …Oooh, glad it’s not my turn to clean up.”

@OneOverTwo  
Seems it bugged other people too. The muzzles are fixed now.

Mishap or not, it’s sweet to see Pinkie be openminded and give Trixie a chance. And I agree that Pinkie will probably find a way to fix it and not hold this against Trixie.

Relax. You think Pinkie can’t salvage this? She’s always wanted to throw a fire party.

Whoops. Looks like somepony spilled the bottle of pain.

No worries, Pinkie Pie probably has a huge stash of plan B.
 
One theme I always seem to see on Trixie: Trouble. And that’s why I like her. xD

Those noses bug me so much.

Trixie is always meant to be a bad pony.