@Background Pony #6FB5  
Reitanna only chose Derpy to be a baker because HUR DUR MUFFINS

@Background Pony #D9FA  
Oh damn, I thought the last part was you. Well, anyway, whoever typed that seems to be one of those fans who is just… I don’t know, find something wrong with most things, but I think I see what you mean.

@Princess Echo  
That was from the comment I copied, not me.

@Background Pony #D9FA  
You didn’t, I already been read all of that.

@Princess Echo  
So, as stated below. How feared she is and how she (Obsidian) is apparently the best at the murdering. Their ability to elude the police and the ridiculous methods of torture and murder, and who they murder.

@Princess Echo  
(Copied and pasted from another comment)
 
Nope, Obsidian is just the sister of Pinkie created before the Maud Pie episode was aired. She’s used in a Cupcakes fanfic spin-off. The whole Pie family (those who are still alive, as Cloudy Quartz and Igneous Rock being murdered by Obsidian) are a group of cannibals and murderers. Obsidian is emotionally repressed and is extremely violent. She favors foals and timid ponies as victims and takes pleasure in torturing them. To a degree where even her sisters can be afraid of her.
 
But do not think this is at all good. This spin-off shows Pinkie in a malicious and hateful light, unlike her playful and joking behavior in the Cupcakes fanfic. Each time Pinkie captures a pony the torture and follow-up death is extremely cruel and personal towards the character. Twilight is driven to insanity by Pinkie of all ponies, who taunts her about not realizing sooner who had been murdering ponies in Ponyville (at this point ponies were hiding in their homes and never came out. Mr. And Mrs. Cake fled to Canterlot, and the whole Pie family moved into Sugarcube Corner.) And how nopony suspected Pinkie.
 
Rarity was gutted by Apple Bloom, who retained her ability of engineering and construction to created a device that literally split her in half. Previously Apple Bloom killed her sister Applejack, and gained her cutie-mark for whatever inane reason.
 
Fluttershy was the victim of Obsidian, who took her sweet time in torturing her. She ripped out her wings, did the standard removal of the cutie-mark, and took out one of her eyes. She managed to escape while the Pie group were torturing Twilight, who also survived.
 
However, Fluttershy was once again caught and presumably murdered, as the Pie group somehow miraculously escaped their prison after the police arrested them. Twilight is presumably still alive in the mental ward of the hospital. Only she and Pinkie are the ones left wielding the Elements of Harmony.
 
I haven’t read anything else of the Muffins trilogy, and would not recommend it. The story is vicious and not at all what Cupcakes Pinkie was about. The killing in Muffins was more or less for the fun of it rather than for baking, and was brutal and personal. While Cupcakes Pinkie relished the murder and would have been excited if her friends had stumbled upon her little murder chamber, instead this Pinkie was angry and hateful and cursed them for finding it, as she stated it would’ve taken forever for their numbers to come up.
 
I hope by spoiling it you don’t read it. It’s a boring waste of time, while the author is just a pompous prick.

@Background Pony #D9FA  
I don’t know her reasoning for Derpy, but I’m sure she may have had a reason, and how are the characters OP…? I don’t really mind the sequel, I’m kind of into the dark stuff and like grimdark anyway. Nothing is wrong with me anyway.
 
I just wish they died at some point or gotten attacked in a fight scene or something.

@Princess Echo  
Oh. Yeah, I’ve read a little bit. I hate it. It seems just like an edgy way to implement an even edgier OC. It seems like the author is just using it to personally attack characters they dislike, not to mention the OPness of the characters. A needlessly violent sequel to a fanfic that was stupidly popular and didn’t need it.
 
Also, really? Derpy? Apple Bloom I can kinda see, but Derpy?

@Background Pony #D9FA  
Dude, seriously? I mean in the “Muffins” series _

@Princess Echo  
Marble doesn’t even have a canon personality, and Babs has since been “reformed”. So what are you even talking about?

Them two are a couple of bitches in the series, and no offenses to the artist or anyone else.

@Princess Echo  
Yeah. It’s an old meme.

@Background Pony #AF14  
Was that suppose to be a joke?

“Tonight: you.”