@Background Pony #012A
The fact that she came up with Twilight’s Test proves that she’s the sort of Trickster Mentor that would arrange for something as convoluted as a show trial for Sunset to teach her a lesson about forgiving oneself.
It would still be a horrible abuse of legal power, and a waste of many Pony’s valuable time.
Edit: Now that I’ve fully read the post, I admit that this actually is in character for Celestia unfortunately (God, the Season 3 Premiere was shit…). Still, it would be a horrible abuse of power.
Wait, what Twilight’s test has to do with it? Are you sure you don’t confuse the show and IDW comics?
@Background Pony Number 17
… You mean the same Celestia that let Discord off the hook? You really think that Celestia is gonna have Sunset arrested for what amounts to a temper tantrum? Really?
Edit: Now that I’ve fully read the post, I admit that this actually is in character for Celestia unfortunately (God, the Season 3 Premiere was shit…). Still, it would be a horrible abuse of power.
@Anon-a-Miss
Your argument only applies to the first Tweet. This tweet is about Sunset avoiding unfinished business and ignoring debts and obligations. This is a completely valid point.
Home is where the heart is. According to that logic everybody not living in his country of birth is living a lie and should go back home. There’s no reason she can’t make amends with Celestia, her family and everypony else she may have wrong and still stay in the human world.
@TexasUberAlles
You need to remember that this is just a story. RL logic and story logic are two different things.
>Personally I think that’s something which has happened offscreen already
Y’know, midquels is a thing. Stories don’t necessarily need to be linear time-wise.
@Background Pony #012A
She needs a closure to a ‘‘Sunset vs Celestia conflict’’ Does she, though? Personally I think that’s something which has happened offscreen already– I mean, it involves Princess Celestia, that would be par for the course– but she seems to have made the conscious choice to move on with her life and has been doing pretty well with that so far.
@TexasUberAlles
She needs a closure to a “Sunset vs Celestia conflict”, but she DON’T need to move to Equestria. Moving to Equestria would mean “running away two times instead of one”, and not whatever those tweets say.
@Gian Song Yim
She is grown adult. If she’s replying to stupid questions, it’s her own fault.
I honestly don’t see the conflict between these two concepts; it seems to me that “the place she needs to be” is “where she can be a good person who helps people without being weighed down by the damage she caused in her homeland”. Sometimes people just need to pack up and Abandon Thread from their own life in order to become the decent person in a new setting that they couldn’t be in the old.
@LanceOmikron
The correspondence isn’t 100%. Pony Celestia’s been alive a lot longer than Human Celestia. Maybe Pony Sunset outlived Human Sunset. (Not implying murder; she could have just been hit by a bus.)
@Background Pony #012A
Time behaves weirdly in the Equestria Girls realm. Sunset should logically be the same age as the pony Shining Armor, but she’s a teenager in Equestria Girls.
The fact that she came up with Twilight’s Test proves that she’s the sort of Trickster Mentor that would arrange for something as convoluted as a show trial for Sunset to teach her a lesson about forgiving oneself.
It would still be a horrible abuse of legal power, and a waste of many Pony’s valuable time.
Edited
… You mean the same Celestia that let Discord off the hook? You really think that Celestia is gonna have Sunset arrested for what amounts to a temper tantrum? Really?
Edit: Now that I’ve fully read the post, I admit that this actually is in character for Celestia unfortunately (God, the Season 3 Premiere was shit…). Still, it would be a horrible abuse of power.
Edited
Your argument only applies to the first Tweet. This tweet is about Sunset avoiding unfinished business and ignoring debts and obligations. This is a completely valid point.
This is the Internet the moment you tell it not to do something, that’s when they go ham.
One of the books actually commented that she already talked to celestia so you may be right that it happened off-screen
You need to remember that this is just a story. RL logic and story logic are two different things.
>Personally I think that’s something which has happened offscreen already
Y’know, midquels is a thing. Stories don’t necessarily need to be linear time-wise.
Edited
She needs a closure to a ‘‘Sunset vs Celestia conflict’’
Does she, though? Personally I think that’s something which has happened offscreen already– I mean, it involves Princess Celestia, that would be par for the course– but she seems to have made the conscious choice to move on with her life and has been doing pretty well with that so far.
At least Sunset’s… happy. That’s looking at the bright side, isn’t it?
Ishi is a dude.
She needs a closure to a “Sunset vs Celestia conflict”, but she DON’T need to move to Equestria. Moving to Equestria would mean “running away two times instead of one”, and not whatever those tweets say.
@Gian Song Yim
She is grown adult. If she’s replying to stupid questions, it’s her own fault.
They said it in Hascon. I think Vynil Fluff said they said it in the FG commentary.
I call bullshit
They said she doesn’t exist
While not important knowing where the old journal went is a neat bit of trivia.
Edited
According to at least one official book that’s already happened.
@Background Human
A bus driven by Sunset!
Edited
The correspondence isn’t 100%. Pony Celestia’s been alive a lot longer than Human Celestia. Maybe Pony Sunset outlived Human Sunset. (Not implying murder; she could have just been hit by a bus.)
EDIT: Ah heck. Someone else made the point first.
Edited
Time behaves weirdly in the Equestria Girls realm. Sunset should logically be the same age as the pony Shining Armor, but she’s a teenager in Equestria Girls.
Hm…a good point you make
I think Ishi is just having fun with it for now.