Welcome to Murder Island (Anthro, NSFW, Spoopy)

@Dave33333  
Dash herself was getting rather close. “P-please…” she muttered between breaths as she dug her face deeper. Her grip on Dana’s cheeks started to loosen as the pressure built up inside her.

@TheSadScubaDiver  
Dana started moving her tongue as best as she could, getting excited.

@Dave33333  
Practically burying her muzzle in, Dash moaned loudly. “Mmmmm!” And with that, nearly collapsed in the orgasm. Moments later, Dana could taste something… distinctive.

@TheSadScubaDiver  
Dana blushes like crazy, starting to take in the juices.

@TheSadScubaDiver
 
@Dave33333  
There was a back door to the cabin that Fluttershy could take, leading to a small area for a shower stall that looked like it was for hosing off. From there she was out in the open, tightening her robe and listening carefully to the sounds coming from the cabin to her right. “Sounds like…someone is hurt?” she thought, as she quietly tip-tied towards the back. It was before she reached the corner of the cabin was when she heard Dash’s voice.
 
“Dashie!” she gasped silently, placing a hand over her lips as she heard the pegasus’ plea. The thought of her friend being the first victim to this island’s game was quickly creeping up on her, setting panic to her mind as she was lost on what to do. Should she surprise them? Should she run and find the owner with Alex? Should she beg the killer not to take her friend’s life?
 
“Snap out of it, Fluttershy - it’s only a contest!” she thought to herself, shaking her head and coming back to grips with reality. “This could be a prank as far as you know…it’s still too early in the day for anything that extreme to happen.” She took a few deep breath and placed a hand over her heart, doing her best to calm herself and work up the nerve to look. She slowly peered her head around the corner. “Just a tiny little peak to-”
 
For a brief second, the color of her face had left her as what she saw what Rainbow Dash and assumingly Dana were truly up to. Then it came back with a hot pink in her cheeks. She was fighting the nerve to squeak out in shock looking at the two mares in action, admittingly stirring up an odd feeling within her. At that point, it was best to leave Dash and Dana to their fun before she gets dragged into it.
 
“By Celestia’s mane and Luna’s tail!” She thought, shaking her head as she made her way back to Alex. “I’m very positive I was not meant to see that! Oh gosh, this is going to be awkward later on!”

@Four Tet  
Alex was waiting in the cabin, wondering what Fluttershy was up to. He sat on one of the chairs with a book in his hands, he was silently reading the first pages to pass the time. The books seemed rather old and in fact didn’t seem to be used that much.

@Dave33333  
@Four Tet  
When Fluttershy encountered Dash, her head was practically muzzle-first buried into Dana, with her own tail lifted up and her groin pressed atop Dana’s face. It was a very compromising position, to say the least.
 
While Dash was trying her damndest to make Dana cum, she didn’t hear or notice her friend. However, she did hear the faintest sound of Fluttershy leaving, and looked up just in time to see Fluttershy’s tail moving back indoors.
 
“Wh–” she barely had time to sputter out. “Fluttershy…?”

@neutralgrey  
It didn’t took long for Fluttershy to come back in and finish changing into her second dress of the day. In fact, one could say that she was moving too quickly - as if there was something or someone she was looking to get away from before it got to her. The face of embarrassment and shame was another telling tale of the explicit act she wasn’t suppose to witness for herself. That kind of intimacy was a heavy obstacle for her to simply climb over, and it would be many attempts before she could reach that point.
 
Regardless, she can only hope Adam didn’t notice her face at the time before she was ready to head out, wearing a tropical red and white summer dress and opting to go barefoot instead, just to make sure she didn’t ruin another pair of shoes on her feet.
 
“All ready to go, Alex~” she said with a smile, doing her best to not break out into a frantic in front of him to confirm what he already knew: Dana and Rainbow Dash was definitely into each other.

@Four Tet  
He blushed at seeing her, her dress was nice but he paid more attention to her cute feet which were now free from their sandals. He only stared at them for a brief moment and looked up at her.
 
“Uh…sure. Let’s go.”
 
He gets up from his seat and puts the book back where he found it, then the two of them leave the cabin and start walking.
 
“So…what did you find?”

@neutralgrey  
“Oh…ummm…”
 
Fluttershy had to think quickly about what to say to Alexander without telling off on Dash and Dana. Saying that you saw two Equestrian mates muzzle deep in each others’ legs isn’t a conversation fit for the norm. She gave the unicorn a cute smile as she came up with an idea.
 
“Well, let’s just say our theory about the wildlife here is busted.” She was still blushing herself, her tail swaying around as she gave Alex the details. “It was just two lovebirds making a nest~”
 
As the couple was heading out to greet the island life once more, Fluttershy had seem to forgot an important piece of clothing she was suppose to wear under her dress - the white bikini that was laying on the changing room bench.

@TheSadScubaDiver  
Dana pulled out, damn close to an orgasm.
 
Dana: (panting) Wh…What?

@Four Tet  
Alex accepted the response without question, if Fluttershy wasn’t freaking out about it he had no reason to worry. The two walked along the beach, Alex oblivious to Fluttershy’s lack of a bra. If he knew he would have offered to go fetch it for her, they had just met but Alex already liked her and had hoped they could be friends even after they leave the island…if they left the island.
 
The two still heard no sounds of animals or even insects, just the sound of the waves. It was almost kind of peaceful, especially now as the sun started to set and the sky was turning orange and purple.

@Dave33333  
Flustered, Dash looked down at Dana. “I, uh… I’m pretty sure somebody saw us just then. I could’ve sworn it was my best friend Fluttershy, too…” Her face was glowing red. “Um… maybe I should finish you off?”
 
With one final, almost energetic burst of action, Dash plunged her face down into Dana’s nethers one more time.

@TheSadScubaDiver  
Dana finally moans out, and came.
 
Dana: Ahhhh… Fuck…

@Dave33333  
As Dana’s juices flowed out, spilling onto her upper thighs, Dash licked across her thighs to clean up as much of it as she could. She then turned over and laid on top of Dana, cuddling her.
 
“How…” She panted for breath. “…was that?”

@TheSadScubaDiver  
Dana: A-Amazing…

@Dave33333  
“Heh, well, I’m glad you thought so.” She gently stroked Dana’s mane.

@TheSadScubaDiver  
Dana: I like it when you stroke my mane.
 
She gently smiles.

@neutralgrey  
Feeling the warm sands under her soles was a lot more comforting than usual, coupled with the gentle sea breeze flowing around them. It was a moment of bliss that allowed the pegasus to put what she witnessed earlier on the back burner of her mind, only to recall it when the time was necessary. She would eventually have to confess to both Rainbow Dash and Dana at some point, best before she was ‘out’ of the contest. It was going to be an awkward conversation, regardless.
 
Speaking of contestants, Fluttershy took notice to Alexander as they walked alongside each other, finding herself taking a real liking to the stallion. He’s been a sweet and patient pony to her up to now and she felt like she could put a lot of her trust into him, possibly even more than that. She also found him to be quite cute in looks, shape, and guilty as she may be for thinking it, his size. She couldn’t help but to giggle to herself - it was like they were living a page out of a romance novel, and they were just rounding out the first chapter. She could only wonder how far they’ll get into the book together…wonder what was written for them at the end. She was thinking ‘going steady’.
 
Finally, she broke the silence of the serene scene, a thought coming to her mind about the scenario with the island wildlife and is absence. “I think there’s another way we should look at this, Alex.” she stated off, looking ahead as the evening sky started to move in. “Since this is a contest and a private resort, this might be all staged. I’ve heard that when contests are held in the open like this, the area has to be closed off to keep their contestants safe.” She looked over to Alex, taking a note to his horn. “I sound silly for asking this, but can you sense any magic that may be keeping the animals away? Or anything close to it?”
 
Fluttershy knew she was taking a stab in the dark at the idea - magical barriers wouldn’t be necessary to zone out an area where the more feral creatures normally reside. On average, just having a few good tamers and a fence would suffice. It may go against the principles she stood for, but she also knew that most ponies wouldn’t want to deal with a leopard prowling in their own kitchen when they got home. All she could do was ask. Not like she would be killed for it…
 
…actually, considering this contest takes place on an island called Murder Island, that might be one of the rules. In that case, she hope she wasn’t an early elimination.
 
((Christ, if work keeps whipping away at me at this rate, I’ll have to write out chapters. Sorry for the late reply!))

@Four Tet  
Alex stopped and tried to hear something, usually there was a slight humming that could be heard by Unicorns when there was some sort of magic in the area they were in. He didn’t hear humming…instead he heard something else. For a split second he heard what sounded like a sigh, this didn’t belong to either him or Fluttershy. His eyes snapped open as he looked to the source, all he saw was the vegitation that surrounded the island. Fluttershy could see the stiffness of his limbs and knew that something had spooked him.
 
(Don’t worry about it!)

@neutralgrey  
She took notice to the way Alexander froze up, her smile suddenly gone when she could feel the tension from his own body. He must have got a read on something he wasn’t suppose to and it felt like it was her fault for asking.
 
“Alex…?” Her voice was gentle and soothing as she got closer to him, taking one of his arms into her own as she offered some sense of comfort to him. “Is it…is it that strong?” She couldn’t hear the sigh herself, but she can tell by the stiffness of his arm whatever he was sending had a firm grip on his attention.

@Four Tet  
He seemed to relax somewhat at feeling the warmth of his new friend, he loosened up and took a deep breath before looking at Fluttershy. It took him a moment to try and figure out what to say to her but he found the words.
 
“I…I think I heard a sigh, a very minor thing but I heard it. It was probably nothing though, maybe the wind, maybe my mind playing tricks on me.”

@neutralgrey  
“A sigh? From which way?”
 
She wasn’t exactly entertaining the idea, but curiosity was stroking at her. It was all due to previous experiences whenever she would go on adventures with her friends. It wouldn’t be the first time someone was pulling a fast one on and she wasn’t expecting it to be the last, either. They were apart of a grand stage play, after all, and at the moment the spotlight was focused on both her and Alex.
 
“I’m not sure how the rules of this game works…” she said to him as she stooped down to, cuddling up to him with her chest pressed against his back. “…but I got a feeling part of the rules is keeping us on our toes. I know I’m on mine, at the moment.”

@Four Tet  
He blushed as he felt her chest on his back, he really just wanted to get out of here and spend some quality time with his new friend.
 
“I-it doesn’t matter, whatever made that noise is probably gone. Let’s go back to the cabins shall we?”
 
(I have classes today so I won’t be on for a good chunk of the day)

@neutralgrey  
(Same here. One more month to go…)
 
“Yeah, that’s probably the best idea.” she said to him. “I’ll admit I’m a little bit creeped out as well.”
 
She gently pulled him back towards the cabins as the evening sky was settling in. “We’ll just ask Mr. Price when we see him. I’m sure he can explain things better then we can find them.”