Welcome to Murder Island (Anthro, NSFW, Spoopy)

@TheSadScubaDiver  
Dana: What would you want me to do?
 
Dana didn’t exactly want her first time to be easy, she wanted it kinda rough.

@neutralgrey  
(All is forgiven. Especially since I took so long myself to make the next move. ^^, Still, you’ve nothing to worry about! Short posts probably make for an easier time, anyway.)
 
“Whew…good~” Fluttershy replied, giving Alexander a warm smile. “Maybe now I can finally relax…well, except for this whole contest.” She shuddered at the thought, her feathers shivering enough to where they drizzled off the moisture gathered. “…oh! You asked me about ghost, right?”

@Four Tet  
“U-uh…”
 
Alexander was still stunned by Fluttershy’s beauty, but finally managed to compose himself. He cleared his throat and smiled.
 
“Yes, ghosts. Personally I don’t believe in ghosts. I like the concept and find it entertaining, but alas I’ve yet to see any real proof of their existence. This might sound cliche but I’m more of a man who believes in what he sees.

@neutralgrey  
Her ears tilted a little as she listened to Alexander’s take on the supernatural, a small, nervous smile on her face as she quietly rubbed one of her arms. “That’s what I keep telling myself on the way here.” she replies, glancing away in thought. “But after the things I’ve been through: turning into a bat pony, seeing windigos with my own eyes, and just recently, surviving a cursed storm…well, I can safely say I’ve seen enough to believe it.”
 
Fluttershy took a look around, taking in the beauty of the island that her and Alex would have to survive in for the next two nights. Even those sights did not help calm her jitters as she was starting to lose her smile.
 
“Even now, I feel like something is off with this island, and it gives me the chills…not even the sharks that helped me here didn’t want to be close.”

@Four Tet  
He took interest in that last statement.
 
“It’s said that animals can…sense the supernatural. I think it has something to do with the way certain animals can sense when a storm is coming. There’s no proof of course of animals sensing the supernatural, it’s just what people say. You know, thinking about it now I don’t think I’ve seen very many animals on this island. It’s…eerily quiet.”
 
Alexander wasn’t about to claim that the island was haunted, there are monsters in the world yes but ghosts? Spirits of the dead? There’s no legitimate documented proof of that…is there? If ghosts aren’t real then what are Wendigos? Perhaps Fluttershy is on to something

@neutralgrey  
“So true…it is eerily quiet.” Alexander couldn’t be more on-the-nose if he could hit it from halfway across Equestria; the island, except for the light breeze and crashing waves against the shore, was eerily quiet. Not even so much as a seagull was up in the sky at the moment, sans miles away in the distance. It didn’t help to put the pegasus at ease any less then where she already was, let alone the connection she had with nature as her own special calling.
 
The irony of it all was that instead of this overwhelming feeling of creepiness making her want to flee, it was drawing Fluttershy to look closer into the matter. “But there has to be a reason outside of ghost that’s causing this.” she said to the unicorn, the nervous tone of her voice vanishing. “Maybe we can find out by taking a walk along the beach, Mr. Alexander?”

@Four Tet  
Alex tried to hide his blush by maintaining an inquisitive attitude, he had to play it cool now more than ever. A walk on the beach with such a beautiful mare? Such a chance only comes once in a lifetime, and if she happens to get scared and cling to his arm? He couldn’t let this opportunity slip from his grasp!
 
“Y-yes. I think that would be best, but first we should take your stuff to your room. Don’t want to be carrying your wet dress around all day after all.”

@neutralgrey  
“Oh!” Her ears perked up as Alexander reminded her of her own luggage, unsure if anything was damaged. “Right, I nearly forgot about that! Just a sec…”
 
She turns towards the small travel suitcase, squatting down to unlock and look inside to see how much damage it took on the open waves. While the inner workings of the case seemed tarnished beyond repair, the contents that were vacuum sealed and tightly packed in were completely spared. A small sigh of relief left her as she at least had other things to wear. “Thank Celestia I took Rarity’s advice, else I’d be stuck wearing this all day%”
 
If Fluttershy wasn’t capturing Alexander’s attention before, she was definitely doing so now. Even though she looked frail by comparison, she carried the right amount of measure to her bust and hips to make up for it. More so on the latter, as the bikini bottom was pressing into the pegasus’ cheeks as she was squatting down, the softness of her body being complemented with the droplets of fresh, tropical water running down her body…no wonder Photo Finish had her as a model.
 
“Alright, now we can head to our room.” Fluttershy said as she turned to Alex, smile on her face with her dress and suitcase in hand. “Lead the way, Mr. Alexander%”

@Four Tet  
He quickly snaps out of his daze and looks at Fluttershy’s face. She was more beautiful than he originally thought.
 
“Uh…sure! And call me Alex.”
 
The two walk to the cabins, Alex already knew the way and led Fluttershy there. It only took a few minutes of walking and they were finally there. Before Fluttershy stood a few cabins one would expect from an island resort.
 
“You’re in luck Fluttershy! There’s one cabin left, and it’s next to mine. Heh, if Dana took her own cabin you’d probably have to bunk with someone but Dana decided to bunk with Rainbow Dash. Don’t tell anyone I said this, but I think the two have a crush on each other. Anyway, let’s get your luggage inside shall we?”

@Dave33333  
“Mmm… What do you think?” Dash started leaving tiny hickeys on Dana’s thighs… her inner thighs… and then gave a single lick across Dana’s pussy.
 
@Four Tet  
@neutralgrey  
Thankfully, the two of them didn’t look in the grass behind Dash and Dana’s cabin, because those two were very naked.

@TheSadScubaDiver  
And to be honest, Dana might start crushing on Fluttershy as well. :/
 
Dana softly moans.
 
Dana: I-I’ll bang you good…

@Dave33333  
“I sure hope so.” Dash yanked down her bottoms–her pussy was already noticeably wet and dripping–and stood up, moving over to Dana’s face. “Ready?” she asked, already lowering herself down on top of Dana.

@TheSadScubaDiver  
Dana: (Excitedly) Yeeeeeees.

@neutralgrey  
Fluttershy made a nervous chuckle as Alex mentioned what antics Rainbow Dash was up to. Whenever she hears the word “crush” and Dash’s name in the same sentence, she knew what it truly means. Mostly through the times Dash had crushed on her and vice versa. “Heheh…y-yeah. I won’t say a word if you don’t.” she said to him, hiding the soft rosey red on her cheeks. “I’m sure they’re just getting to know each other…l-let’s just head inside%!”
 
Fluttershy pushed the door open to her cabin, peaking inside to see what it had to offer to her and Alex. “I’m guessing there’s not mu~~!” She stopped in her tracks, gasping in awe as she took in the decor and accommodations ~~ it was decorated like it was fit for a queen. It was wide, spacious and had silk ribbons hanging in arcs upon the ceiling and soft lanterns along the walls. In the middle of the hardwood floors was a hand-crafted spring that was heated through the kindling under its base, its waters spiced with leaves and flowers from the island itself. To the left of them were a couple of bookshelves, stacked with various literature about the history and wildlife of the island, along with a few romance and fantasy novels to boot. To their right, a stone kettle kitchen complete with a stew pot and hand-carved utiensles. At the very back was her own king-sized bed, surrounded by silk curtains and littered with pillows to spare. Next to it would be her dresser all of her clothes would be settled in. And in the corner of it all was a small area for her to change clothes into, a woven boarder being the only thing that kept prying eyes from peaking in through the windows around the place.
 
“This is…this is wonderful%!” she said with a soft gasp, her tail swaying back and forth with excitement. “I don’t even think I’m suppose to have this cabin my myself - this looks like a couple’s dream!” She paused, blushing for a moment as she looked over to Alex. “W-well, I mean…eeehhh let’s just say ‘I love it’.” she said with a bashful smile.

@Four Tet  
“Heh, can’t blame you. I had the same reaction when I saw my cabin. It seems the owner of the island spared no expense when building these cabins. I’m almost disappointed we’ll be here for just a few days, in fact this is all feels unreal. I mean not only are we spending the nights in cabins meant for very rich people for free, we’re also getting paid for it. It’s almost like there’s a…catch.”
 
He briefly forgot about Fluttershy’s revelation about how animals seem to fear this island and how it might be haunted. Now it came back to him, perhaps the catch was that this island really was haunted? This was a thought that frightened Alexander, and brought back memories of him as a colt cowering in his bed at night.
 
“Well…anyway. Leave your luggage here and let’s go investigate the island. Perhaps we’ll find the real reason why animals don’t like his place.
 
He hoped the reason was mundane and normal and not paranormal.

@neutralgrey  
“Sure thing%” she said to him. “I’ll be a moment, though. Still feel like a siren fresh out the ocean.” A cute giggle came from the pegasus as she headed over to her dresser, placing the case on the floor and unpacking all that was inside. “You can stay around, if you like. I just need to change%”
 
She managed to grab a couple of towels from the dresser for her mane and tail, as well as two sealed bags that contained another summer dress and swimwear in one, and a few mane care products in the other. She then made her way towards the changing room, pulling back the covering.
 
“Oh, nice - there’s a bathrobe back here!” She said aloud. “Looks quite soft, too…must mean there’s a spa nearby.” She steps in, hang up the wet dress she had to dry off on the top of the cover before folding it back, hiding everything but her feet that pattered against the floor.
 
Then she unwrapped her sandals, pushing them gently to the side. Then off came her bikini as she hung it next to her dress…then there was a soft moan from her lips as she finally got the chance to stretch her limbs, the tip of her wings peering over the top of the changing room covers.
 
“Mmmphh…feels so much better%” she said with a sigh. “Almost done, Alex! Just need a moment to brush up%!” It was then she unpacked the soft brush from her bag and started smoothing out the hairs of her coat, humming a gentle melody to herself in the process…until she heard something from behind the cabin wall, muffled and fainted.
 
 
@Dave33333  
“What the…?” Her ears twitched and turned towards the sound, causing her to press her cheek against the wall to get a close listen. She couldn’t make out what was happening at first - were those grunts of a boar or the cooing of a jabara she was hearing?
 
“Hmm…I think we might be wrong about our theory, Alex.” Fluttershy says to the unicorn. “These walls are pretty thick to hear anything, but I’m hearing something going on in the back…I’m gonna check it out.”
 
She slips into the robe and steps out from the room, her mane and tail still wrapped up neatly in towels. The robe was almost identical to the ones at the spa her and Rarity frequent, sans the maroon coating and black trim. “I’m sorry if I’m holding up anything, Alex. I just want a tiny little peek at what’s happening behind this cabin, if that’s okay~”

@Dave33333  
Dash grinned, then lowered her pussy onto Dana’s lips. Simultaneously, she gripped Dana’s hips and lifted them up to her mouth, already taking another lick.
 
She had no suspicions that anyone could see her.

@TheSadScubaDiver  
Dana started eating Dash out, digging her tongue in.
 
Dana didn’t really give a fuck if she was caught.

@Four Tet  
“Oh? Uh…go ahead.”
 
Alex was still lost in thought. The weight of the situation was finally bearing down on him. Ghosts couldn’t be real, they couldn’t. He was being ridiculous, magic exists yes, but there’s no proof of deceased people returning from the grave to haunt the living.

@Dave33333  
Dash moaned loudly, then returned the favor and moved closer, feeling the every fold of Dana’s marehood with her tongue and specifically aiming for the ones intended to produce the most pleasure.

@TheSadScubaDiver  
Dana’s legs twitched out. Her tongue quickly dug in deeper.

@Dave33333  
Gripping Dana’s buttcheeks tightly, Dash continued her process. Dana got the sense that Dash had a lot of experience with this.
 
Dana could also taste some of Dash’s early excitement.

@TheSadScubaDiver  
Dana was doing a pretty good job for being a newbie. She spread her legs out a bit more.

@Dave33333  
“Mmmm!” Dash moaned into Dana’s nethers, getting wetter. She continued her oral assault then, hoping to push her to ultimate orgasm.

@TheSadScubaDiver  
Dana was getting close, trying to hold back, she wiggles her muzzle around as well as moving her tongue around.