At this point, this thing almost seems like concept art made in the early days of the movie designs. It’s pretty crude compared to what they went with:
Something to fix: In the actual cardboard standee, you can see that the light reflections in Twilight’s eyes have little blue outlines around them. In this image, they’re flat white.
Thank you for doing this breakdown and analysis - the extra strokes along with the shading really makes me curious to see how they’ll handle this in the movie. In a lot of ways, the original show designs were all about making it as easy as possible to crank out the shows with minimum tweaking because a character turned or because of a change in camera angle.
I think that adding all these extras, plus having an indication of light sources, will help make the movie pop on the big screen, but … now I feel like I’m going to end up watching sight lines and shadows for the whole movie just to figure out what they’re doing with the puppets :)
@Background Pony #55A9
Well this vector is based off of a picture from Tara Strong next to a cardboard cutout of Twilight, which was slanted away from the camera a bit.
Looking at the changes, they’re good, but I copied the image into MS Paint and stretched it out just a tiny bit more, and in my opinion, looked a little bit better. No big deal, though.
@Archonix
I know that. I know that this is a vector from a cardboard cutout, but I think it should be readjusted to account for the fact that the cardboard was at an angle from the camera taking a picture of it.
Maybe if you weren’t seeing drama in anything and everything and verbally hand-wringing over it, you’d actually be able to get it off your mind for once?
@rdibp
And even MORE good news: There’s no drama in sight. granted, there’s at least one or two people on here that have mixed reception, but no idiot drama in sight. ^^
If they are doing redesigns, whether for the movie or the new animation studio regardless, the drama will likely be a repeat of the Equestria Girls designs (though not to quite as epic of proportions). People will complain until we actually see how good the models look in motion
After the movie, they will continue airing the show.
I know.
The alledged redesigns are for the movie.
I think that adding all these extras, plus having an indication of light sources, will help make the movie pop on the big screen, but … now I feel like I’m going to end up watching sight lines and shadows for the whole movie just to figure out what they’re doing with the puppets :)
Well this vector is based off of a picture from Tara Strong next to a cardboard cutout of Twilight, which was slanted away from the camera a bit.
the face looks weird, but this may just be an early design.
I know that. I know that this is a vector from a cardboard cutout, but I think it should be readjusted to account for the fact that the cardboard was at an angle from the camera taking a picture of it.
On the original you can see the side of the cut-out board plain as day.
Maybe if you weren’t seeing drama in anything and everything and verbally hand-wringing over it, you’d actually be able to get it off your mind for once?
It’ll be worth the wait, hopefully.
Well okay, even do it’s bit by bit. But I guess that’s better than nothing.
Bit by bit, the fandom’s slowly starting to return to it’s former glory. I’m now at peace here.
That’s good news and looks like the more time passed the mature users in derpibooru.
And even MORE good news: There’s no drama in sight. granted, there’s at least one or two people on here that have mixed reception, but no idiot drama in sight. ^^
These redesigns aren’t really that drastic. They look like the original models, just more detailed.