So much as they are all known and revealed scumbag that eat their own, (look up phelous and lupa leaving, for one) the idea of an aggregate site just isn’t that appealing anymore. Everyone just goes to youtube or cultivates their own fan following. Nowadays TGWTG is just around to provide doug some hits and filler content until he can make new NC or force out some blogs. If you look at the views/comments of any given producer they are usually quite low.
People now gather their own followers and do their own thing. The TGWTG concept has waned and is on its last legs.
So far as them being SJW; yeah, no shit. That was pretty obvious from the get go. Untalented people talking about other people’s creations and putting social spins on them. It is practically potting soil for their ilk.
Couldn’t have said it better myself.
I can remember a time when Youtube was the stepping stone to sites like TGWTG, ScrewAttack (anyone remember them?), GameFailures, etc. Nowadays, Youtube (plus things like Patreon, Blip, Dailymotion, Vimeo, whatever) have become a satisfying endgame once someone builds up a following, thus negating the need for an aggregate site with one or two huge-name talents to bring the viewers in.
As for me, I discovered TGWTG around April of 2009, having been a fan of SF Debris/Confused Matthew beforehand, thus prefer more analytical reviews to riffing reviews.