Sweet F.A.
@Don’t
@Meanlucario
It’s something I’ve seen a lot, in both my comments and in general online discourse. But it is so stupid, so utterly inane, and so easily debunkable, that anyone who still uses it immediately proves that they have nothing of value to add to the world.
Because first of all, while it can help your understanding of the media in question, being an accomplished artist/musician/filmmaker is not necessary for understanding art/music/films. You don’t need to be Gordon Ramsay to recognize bad food. You don’t need to be a politician to be annoyed by the decisions politicians make.
And secondly, it only ever seems to apply to negative feedback. You never hear people saying the same about positive feedback, like “You can’t like or appreciate this solo because you aren’t a musician.” So it becomes increasingly clear that people only say this because they’re butthurt that people have opinions.