@kleptomage
I think it deserves the GOTY spot for its uniqueness. Elden Ring as a single player game, gives catharsis and a online experience unlike most other non-Souls AAA games out there.
In the years where big AAA single player games
give easy mode to cater to a wider audience, Elden Ring demands that you the player, invest time and effort learning it.
It’s difficult but it’s fair (well, at least it should be), and the return is less diminishing, the more effort you put into it. I.e, the skill ceiling is high and only reached by those who really put in the research and training to GIT GUD.
If I’m playing Politics I’d totally put Elden Ring as GOTY even if ppl didn’t vote for it. Reason being: to push the industry into a direction that is less Console Exclusive with pretty graphics that is basically Live Action TV Series with interactive elements.
With many games I felt satisfied, like I’ve finished the game myself after watching a 6 hours CUTSCENES video on Youtube. That’s kinda not ideal.