General Tag Discussion

@Zeb  
Oh, thanks! I’ll go add the artist tag on the image I linked, then. I didn’t think to search hoodie because clothing tags are rarely applied if at all and it’s generally too unreliable

Does this pic  
should be suggestive or questionable?
 
Also there are similar pictures that are also tagged suggestive:  
, and

We should have a tag for graphic card comparison memes, but I don’t know what to call it. Examples:  
 
 

When considering a non-consensual tag for an image, should we take the whole series (in this case a comic) into account? Or is each image judged on its own?
 
The one I am looking at is (it ranges from suggestive to explicit):
 

This image is blocked by your current filter - click here to display it anyway

your current filter.

 

This image is blocked by your current filter - click here to display it anyway

your current filter.

 
These two images on their own (or even together) imply a non-consensual situation that is not BDSM.
 

This image is blocked by your current filter - click here to display it anyway

your current filter.

 
Then this one pulls a bait-and-switch and would imply that they had agreed on the situation in the first two, and that it is just a BDSM scene.
 
What do?

@Damaged  
We usually tag images based on the content of each individual image.

@Zeb  
Thanks. Hitting those two with “nonconsensual” then.
 
To be completely honest, the whole comic takes a “tell, don’t show” approach to BDSM consent. Nopony checks on safety, no effort is made (or shown to be made) on ensuring they can still tap out. Bleh…

Is there any chance of having WebM files automatically have the webm tag?
 
Not everyone knows how to do things like: -original_format:webm

Also, I recently reported a user for not including the source in any of their uploads, and the staffer who actioned it messaged me that they were sourced from volatile image boards (IE: any links would be useless anyway). Maybe it would be a good idea to have a tag (like derpibooru exclusive) to cover such images and exclude them from a need for a source link?

@Damaged  
Do you mean places like 4chan? If that’s the case, see if the board in question has a site where its posts are archived (in /mlp/’s case, you would probably use desuarchive) and give it a source from there.

Something seems strange about these being ‘safe’:  
>>1510981  
>>1510982  
Would that be the correct rating?

@Exedrus  
Her anus is bleeding, probably not.

Hi there! I just got done with my regular rundown on all of my art uploads to check the tags and tag changes on them. Surprisingly I only found one I had to come to y’all for.
 
Someone tagged this image with shipping tags:  
 
And while I seriously do not want to reduced the QuibbleLight tag, it’s not really a shipping picture since it’s mostly one sided and probably nonconsenual. Is thereally any tags I can use for thi’s situation where there’s something like this?

@Binkyt11  
I think you can just safely remove the shipping tags. Your image, you know what is and isn’t intended by it.
 
If you want, you can try the tags one sided shipping and drunk twilight.

@Zeb  

 
The fact that there’s a tag for that shouldn’t surprise me but I am surprised nonetheless.

@Zharkaer  
Well, the staffer just dismissed the claim, and I am not bored enough to search for the sources of dozens of images without even knowing what image board they are from.

cutiespark ⟶ cutie spark

Is there a way for us to separate the OC:Bubble Lee tag and the OC:Imago tag when there’s no reason to add the later. Story imagines and those with her as a changeling is one thing, but her just as Lee with no indication that this is also Imago is another.

@Meanlucario  
[shrug] If people want to add the tag and the artist doesn’t mind. Not much to do about it.  
If someone’s tryin to search for/exclude the actual changeling appearance they’d have to add changeling to the search.
 
Bubble Lee seems just one of those rare situations that muddles tags a bit~

@Zeb  
I’ve noticed.

Should this pic be tagged SciTwiShimmer (shipping of Sci-Twi and Sunset)?:  
>>1512843t (deleted)
 
As it has them in it’s source – scitwishimmer, sunlight, twishimmer, sciset, twiset – I know it wasn’t a shippy moment in the original (at least officially XD), but the artist, may interpret it as a corner stone in Sci-Twi’s and Sunset’s romantic relationship, seeing the shipping tags.

@BackgroundLoL  
Ehh… I’d say no. There’s nothing within the image itself to indicate shipping. If people want to interpret it as such, sure, but being a drawing of the scene from the movie. I’m not sure it fits.
 
That said, I personally wouldn’t stop someone if they felt like adding the tags either.

@Zeb  
Ok.

Why the “alicorn” tag implication is removed from Scitwilicorn and also why mod removed “alicorn” tag from all pictures of ponied up Sci-Twi with alicorn wings?

@Markiz93  
Because she’s not an alicorn.  
She has no horn and is not a pony.
 
The same as we don’t tag ponied up Rainbow Dash with Pegasus.  
Or ponied up Rarity with Unicorn.  
Or ponied up Applejack with Earth pony.

@Zeb  
What about ponied up pony-Twi?